What if Salman – SRK clash?

Part 2 of ‘Ask Joginder’. 5 more questions from Indicine readers answered!

The buzz around each Shahrukh and Salman starrers is higher than any other superstar. What would be the most precise expectations shall they release their films on the same date? – Hamza Khan

  • The way things stand today, neither of the two superstars nor those who would invest in their films would even dream of such a clash. Still, if their films actually decide to release on the same day, history would be created at the box office, fans would be out on the streets (practically so), there won’t be any space in media to write/talk about any other film for at least a fortnight leading to the release and the biggest beneficiaries would be ‘aam junta’ who would be guaranteed ton loads of entertainment from all quarters, even if not the film itself.

Don’t you think there is so much negativity surrounding the release of any Shahrukh Khan starrer, especially after Ra.One? – Tinku Jain

  • Others have seen a worst fate! Salman Khan has faced it, Akshay Kumar too was troubled and even Amitabh Bachchan wasn’t spared! On the contrary, Shahrukh Khan has still delivered three back to back 100 crore successes and doesn’t have a flop to his name for the longest time. One solid film (just like Salman enjoyed with ‘Dabangg’, Akshay with ‘Housefull 2’ and Big B with KBC) and fortunes would reverse in a big way for Shahrukh as well. All he needs is the kind of content to back his superstardom. ‘Chennai Express’ followed by ‘Happy New Year’ should be two such films.

What is the difference in word of mouth/audience feedback between Jab Tak Hai Jaan and Veer Zaara in India? – Rick

  • Big. ‘Veer Zaara’, even though not as appreciated as ‘Dil Toh Paagal Hai’, had still seen better word of mouth for a Yash Chopra-Shahrukh Khan combo when compared to ‘Jab Tak Hai Jaan’.

What is the expectation from Krrish 3? Is it possible for the film to beat the record First Day of Ek Tha Tiger? – Sayed Abid Shah

  • Very huge. It would beat the record First Day of ‘Ek Tha Tiger’ by a very huge margin. Releasing one year down the line from now. ‘Krrish 3′ has enough potential for Roshans to be actually strategising the film’s release to enter the record ’50 crore First Day’ club. Yes, you read it here first!

‘Jab Tak Hai Jaan’ was expected to crush ‘Son Of Sardaar’. But do you think latter has emerged as a bigger success? As the days have passed, the difference in collections is reducing? – Priya Thakur

  • For starters, ‘Jab Tak Hai Jaan’ was never expected to crush ‘Son Of Sardaar’; it was only the wishful thinking of certain fanatics within trade and industry. ‘Son of Sardaar’ was always hot. Though none of the two films are extraordinary, ‘Son of Sardaar’ has seen lesser brickbats coming it’s way than ‘Jab Tak Hai Jaan’. However from collections perspective, the Shahrukh Khan starrer is still leading Ajay Devgn’s film. The films have 17 open days for them till the release of ‘Talaash’ and there is still some time to announce one of the two being a bigger success, both on absolute scale as well as on a comparative note.

Joginder Tuteja tweets @tutejajoginder

You can ask Joginder a question – just fill the form below.

Joginder

[contact-form-7 id=”40462″ title=”Ask Joginder”]

Advertisements

152 Comments

  • hrithik fans,tell me one difference between hrithik and ranbeer.even ranbeer’s offbeat films getting 100 crores collections.

  • Aakash Dude Hrithik is a superstar doesn’t matter what you say about him or compare him with whomever you want.If you have any idea about Box office than you can watch 2000 to 2008 from Hrithik’s career which is better than any other actor barring Srk who a bit ahead of HR.Now don’t bring ur sillylogic to campare him with RK .

  • I was big srk fan..i was …but after seeing jthj, i really hate him,,now i came to know no one is bigger than mr. Salman khan….

  • 50 cr it would be impossible for two reason no1 diwali time
    2.release friday which is working time…..it can beat ek tha tiger record but you can not compare this two ek tha tiger release on 15 th aug …..you can compare dabbang2 opening day with krishh3 as both release on working day….hrithik is much better actor than salman no doubt…hrithik has all power to broke opening day record…krishh3 already has 2 times more buzz than any other film….on the other hand it is the only film which can challenge 3 idot as hrithik film dont run like all sallu 2 weeks run film

  • lets compare dabbang2 opening day with kriss3 ..as both open on non holyday…then all sallu fan get their answer…that is more fair

  • sorry if dabbang2 relese on holyday ..compare readdy opening dabbang opening with krishh3…dont compare holyday opening with non holyday

  • those who have doubt on hrithik all get your answer on 1 st nov?????????just wait…..even sallu non holyday realese dabbang and readdy did nothing on its opening day…

  • now a days SRK movie can’t stand in front of ajay devgan …. and clash salman …. SRK’s movie will do business like ram gopal verma ki aag

  • hrithik fan,let me tell you.amir’s career till 2000 to 2009 is much much better than hrithik.amir gave minimum 1 hit or super hit every year(apart from 2005-mangal pandey).and,hrithik has just 4 or 5 hits in those 8 years with double flops.and,releasing 1 film after 2 years,anyone can give a hit.salman was releasing 4 films per year that time,but now he is releasing just 2 films.and result you can see.hrithik is so much over hyped actor of india.

  • Thank you for answering my question.
    It is now proven that SRK has 3 back to back 100cr films, and he hasn’t had a failure in the longest time.
    Truly one more solid movie from SRK and he will regain his top position.

  • @manish dont you know Aamir was not there in bollywood between 2001 to 2005.His only hits are in last dacade till 2008 am not including 2009 because that year change the whole ranking system,
    Dil chahta hai- just hit,Mangal pandey Lagaan – hit,Rang de Basanti- hit,Fanna hit superhit Gajhni atbb.Hrithik’s KNPH,KMG,KRISH,Dhoom 2 all are BB not including KKKG,JA was hit,Mission Kashmir was semi hit.About Flops every superstar has some flops.From 2000 era Hrithik has 3 highest grosser movie of the year which is equal as any khans or more.Aamir has 2,Srk has 3,Salman has 4 including this years ETT.You seem to be a just another Hrithik hater who will ignore all this.So keep doing all this.I dont have time to discuss with you anymore.

  • Movie: Chennai Express (2013)
    Director: Rohit Shetty
    Starcast: Shahrukh Khan, Deepika Padukone
    Banner: Red Chillies Entertainment, UTV Motion Pictures
    Music Director: Vishal Dadlani, Shekhar Ravjiani,
    Release Date: 2013 {Eid Release}
    For more details: Chennai Express Movie Page

  • Can you Salman fans please get a little bit more educated and learn how to type in correct English? It is very difficult to understand your wording. At least Hrithik can be considered for a Hollywood film. Hollywood directors probably just laugh during a Salman Khan film, and scratch their head on why such filth is being made and called cinema.

  • Movie: Chennai Express (2013)
    Director: Rohit Shetty
    Starcast: Shahrukh Khan, Deepika Padukone
    Banner: Red Chillies Entertainment, UTV Motion Pictures
    Music Director: Vishal Dadlani, Shekhar Ravjiani,
    Release Date: 2013 {Eid Release}
    For more details: Chennai Express Movie Page

  • salmans boxoffice stamina will b really tested when he @least gives a hit status without action or remake film…but the most probable results would be disaster,flop,below average max average…first you salman khan fans need to know wat is his ability in acting skills…nd u say hahk ,jus watch d movie once and c his name cmes after madhuri dixit..its a madhuri dixit starter…lolz…and noentry and partner are nt blockbusters bcoz of salman ….the fact iz aftr hahk,he has no films to be remembered….his second innings statrtdwith dabaang…nt evn wanted as veer was a flop cming aftr wanted..and cming to hrithik aftr kmg,kites nd guzaarish wer meant to b flop..coz kites story was a bakwaas,…nd guzaarish was absolute out of reach film for audience…but still kites mamgd 10.cr opening despite mysore and non holday release…wer 2idiots was a 13 cr with holday release…guzaarish was classic nd earnd respect 4 hrihtik….nd plz salman khan fans try to rem d tymes when ppl evn doesnt knw wen his film came and of from theatres,….

    rem marigold?????all time disaster i ll say it earning 80 lakhs life time collection in 2007…haha…spit on face…its not salmankhan has lot of fans ,its onli srk haters hav bcum salman fans…dts y he has lot of fans…now u salman khn fans still dont realize den derz no illiterate ppl than u…shut d fck up nd praise ur fav actor ,don try to degrade others…other wise i need to say d real thng…

  • why dont salman khan fans listen to the truth
    others have seen a worst fate! Salman Khan has faced it, Akshay Kumar too was troubled and even Amitabh Bachchan wasn’t spared! On the contrary, Shahrukh Khan has still delivered three back to back 100 crore successes and doesn’t have a flop to his name for the longest time.

  • why dont salman khan fans listen to the truth
    others have seen a worst fate! Salman Khan has faced it, Akshay Kumar too was troubled and even Amitabh Bachchan wasn’t spared! On the contrary, Shahrukh Khan has still delivered three back to back 100 crore successes and doesn’t have a flop to his name for the longest time. since 2005

  • i just wonder why dont salman khan fans listen to the truth
    others have seen a worst fate! Salman Khan has faced it, Akshay Kumar too was troubled and even Amitabh Bachchan wasn’t spared! On the contrary, Shahrukh Khan has still delivered three back to back 100 crore successes and doesn’t have a flop to his name for the longest time. since 2005

  • @afraz: ACTING WHAT YOU PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT? IRFAN KHAN, NASIR SAHAB,OM PURI are far better then any others, but it’s is not about acting only in the industry it’s about looks style and EX factor otherwise this people will be superstars.

  • @joe: the problem with you guys are never accept the facts in today’s world salman in way ahead of SRK which shows in box office.

  • Its just a matter of tym …………..
    One gud movie and srk will again lead d race…..itz ra 1 which effects dont2 buisness bcoz of its (-)ve word of mouth..
    If ra 1 would hav bettr cncpt it would surely had crossed 250crores.
    See ra 1 2nd day collection its 25 crores( 1st day was diwali puja still it managed18 crores in tamil + hindi)

  • D romantic movie lyk jthj is earning more dan 110 crores den wat is wron in dis…if it was salman’s movie den it would surely b a flop…look at london dream, mai aur mrs khanna,yuvraaj…many more..
    F any actor can deliver hits wid cincept lyk jthj.. it is srk and ranveer….bcoz both r born to romance…

  • @aki:bt om puri etc etc cannot be superstarts lyk hr,sallu,srk,aamir etc….dey dont ve such star power so dey are care free actors nd can do any roles….but superstars hav to keep der status nd fans in mind nd do films..

  • u cnt mek sallu fans undrstand coz dey r uncivilised, most probably skul drop outs ! dey tlk abt salman’s power haha ghar me sher , bahar chuha !! hrithik is d only actor who is matchable to hollywood standard ! evn kristen stewart goin gaga ovr hrithik n wnts to wrk wid him, he was considered by fox studios fr tom cruise starrer knight and day remake n nt ur salman coz his standards r low !! d day ppl r fed up wid d old stuff of salman, dat day i vl luv to c d faces of salman fans !! evn tho i hate srk bt atleast he knws hw to act !!

  • black hell w_yne: bhai aapne hit super hit to dedi salman ki… but usme salman ko kitna credit mila .. acting kaha hai…nahi acting kahi bhi…. as per your information … i will tell u…..

    Hum Aapke Hain Kaun 1994….all time blockbuster …… family movie … rajshre prod. n well contain
    Hum Saath Saath Hain 1999…..hit……same here
    Biwi No1 1999…..hit …… family drama.. but no acting
    hum dil de chuke sanam 1999….blockbuster…..romance,family drama.. but ajay over then salman
    jeet 1996…..hit ….. cause of sunny deol
    pyar kiya to darna kya 1998…hit …..cause of well contain..n good songs..overacting
    Judwaa 1997….hit….cause of idiot type of songs n contains n overacting
    bandhan 1998…hit…..emotional contain
    har dil jo pyar karega 2000..semi hit…..
    tere naam 2003…hit
    mujhse shadi karogi………..2004…hit
    no entry 2005 super hit
    meine pyar kyun kiya 2005 semi hit
    partner 2007..blockbuster
    wanted 2009…super hit
    dabangg 2010..all time blockbuster
    ready 2011…blockbuster
    bodyguard 2011 blckbuster
    ek tha tiger 2012 blockbuster

    sab hit ya super hit to de di 25 yrs. ke career mai… flops ka record aur jyada hai… mere bhai….

  • Now WELcome Back SOUTH Remake KHan and His Assistant….. i Mean Salman khan for Dabang-2 and his Assistant Akshay Kumar ..for Khiladi-786….Total… Both r Non-sense Movie..NOn-sense Songs..Meaningless songs,movie,acting,dialoge,story,actors………Pls Must watch…Both Movies… Hahahahah

  • krish 3 would certainly have at least 45 first day but it won’t break any records because krish 3 is releasing after eid and salman is again releasing a film on eid so his film would have already broken every record and sharukh khan films are also releasing so krish 3 will not break any record but would have the first day more than 45 crore indeed.

Leave a Comment