Shivaay Review

Ajay Devgn has been known for his acting talent, but his productions and directorials don’t always work out. ‘Raju Chacha’ and ‘U Me Aur Hum’ are the two big failures that come to mind. Now he’s back directing and starring in ‘Shivaay’, a mega-budget film on which he has invested 2 years of his life. The clash with ‘Ae Dil Hai Mushkil’ has been the mainstay of entertainment news. But at the end of the day, the two movies will work based on their content. Does ‘Shivaay’ live upto expectations? Let’s find out.

Story: Shivaay (Ajay) is an adrenaline junkie who guides tourists in the slopes of the Himalayas. He meets a Bulgarian girl called Olga (Erika Kaar) there. After a rather illogical avalanche incident, they get stuck in a translucent tent between two peaks. They make love there and Olga gets pregnant. She doesn’t want to have the baby, but damn what the woman wants, she has to bear the baby because the guy says so. The child arrives and Olga leaves for Bulgaria. Gaura (Abigail Eames), their child discovers after a few years that her mother lives in Bulgaria and after an incessant plea with her father they arrive in Bulgaria. This is where things go haywire and Shivaay has to fight goons across the streets and valleys and gullies. To know the resolution, watch the movie.

Shivaay Movie Review

Shivaay Movie Review

Review: The writers of Shivaay are too literal in nature, too reliant on connecting the story of Shiva with Shivaay, but it all starts feeling a bit hollow after the first few minutes which showcase the beauty of the Himalayas (alas, the mountain scenes were shot in Bulgaria). There’s not much logic in the film but that could have been overlooked if it was entertaining. It is not that Shivaay is dull, there are quite a few entertaining sequences in it. There’s a good 2 hour action drama movie hidden in the 3 hour long movie.

Shivaay is technically brilliant, the topography of the mountains have been shot well. It is reminiscent of Hollywood movies like Everest and so on. The production design is top notch (this is something that was missing in U Me Aur Hum). The editing of Shivaay is where it falters majorly. So many scenes go on and on without any end point in sight. The music of Shivaay is solid as songs like Bolo Har Har, and Darkhaast make a very good impact.

Acting: Ajay Devgn is in decent form in Shivaay both as a director and as an actor. The effort he has put into this movie clearly shows. He’s done a lot right as an actor and as a director but he also misfires a lot in both departments. Having said that, kudos to him for taking up the challenge of handling everything, the end result notwithstanding. Shivaay is the Ajay Devgn show from top to bottom. Erika Kaar doesn’t have a lot to do but she’s decent. The little girl Abigail Eames is cute. Girish Karnad and Sayessha are adept at whatever little they’ve been given to do.

Conclusion: There’s a neat little movie hiding in Shivaay somewhere and unfortunately it has been left to the viewer to discover that movie. Shivaay is not a trainwreck by any means, far from it actually. Many scenes and sequences are entertaining and engross the viewers. But it also zones out for few minutes in between those scenes. Shivaay deserves to be watched at least once for the monumental effort undertaken by a man called Ajay Devgn. He gives it his all in all departments. Watch it and form your own opinions.

Pros:

  • Breathtaking visuals
  • Good music
  • Great action choreography
  • Ajay gives it his all and more!

Cons:

  • Isn’t entertaining all the way through
  • Too long and somewhat illogical
  • Story is too threadbare

Rating: ★★★☆☆ Watch for action, visuals and Ajay Devgn!

Advertisements

86 Comments

  • It may be a tough time for Indicine to handle both the movies and post their relevant news & collections. You guys are doing well and deserve a pat. Keep up the great work and All the best !!!!!! :-)

  • Finally the Big Ego Of ajay Devgan has been Thrashed by Ranbir kapoor …..
    Diwali only deserves for a good film and ajay is always wasting our diwali by films like SOS ,Golmaal 3 and Return , And all the best . Ajay devgans ego is thrashed .Happy for Bollywood now

  • watched it today…guys its not worth it….we work hard n earn 300 bucks and wasting so many bucks on movie like shivaay is stupidity… I donno about adhm but shivaay is not up to the mark…

  • this is pre-diwali period affect sure. Really shivaay is something new experience on big screen. I think after Sunday will pick up sure. bolo Har Har Har

  • @sunny makkhiholic
    it is very painfull for me to see akki fans talking about stardom.lol;-(
    i still remember s26 vs abcd clash.despite no notable face value it had opened upto s26 level.ha ha ha ha
    90’s ka sabse bada disaster star.90’s ka article yaad hain naa.
    2007 year ko agar iske carrier se hata dein then he is below than even vivek, tushar lol
    2013-14 60cr se upar nahi japaraha tha.2015 mein despite content rich 80cr se upar nahi jatatha.aur ab iss saal neraaj papa and patriotic flim ke bhorose 100 kya paar karli apne aap ko superstar samajh ta hein .don’t worry ajay ne jab 32cr ka opening diya tha tab gobora 15 bhi par nehi kiya tha.
    Aur ek baat aaj msd ne RR cross kar chuki hai.:-O
    neraaj with ssr 133cr
    neeraj with so called nonholiday king 90cr.:-P
    shame on canadian star’s stardom
    #A SALMAN FANl

  • It’s not about logic!! There r lot of illogical movies in world!!but the main dfawback is Shivaay is not at all an Entertaining Movie(also a prolonged Movie) !! Apart from Ajay & Top notch Visuals;nothing much r there!!!so it is clear that Indicine is being little bit free handed to give 3 stars unlike Most of the reviewers who has given 1.5-2.5!!I am not in favour to ny of 2…but seems ADHM is clearly being liked more by Mango peoples as well as by Critics!!

  • It will be same like Dilwale and Bajirao. Adhm has opened better but Shivaay will Win the race for sure.

  • Bdw Indicine great work You r doing in this busy period!! But i have a question ,have You changed Your reviewer???in ADHM Article i also noticed a new style of writing!!just curiosity?

  • SHIVAAY is nothing than ADHM…..
    SHIVAAY has all flop movie related elements..
    But, ADHM is much better than Ajay Devgn’s movie…..
    PAST HISTORY—
    Rajneeti was Super-Hit or Blockbuster for just RANBIR KAPOOR(son of Rishi Kapoor, grandson of Raj Kapoor)….

  • Shivaay turned out to be an above average movie.. I was waiting for Shivaay because Ajay tried a Shahrukh Khan that is trying to take Bollywood to the next level in terms of VFX. Shivaay was quite a bit too stretched… Could’ve been cut down by at least 20-25 minutes..
    But I wasn’t disappointed by the VFX Action in the movie. The VFX is really really good for a Bollywood movie. I won’t mind calling it the best VFX so far..
    Hope Ajay hadn’t directed Shivaay and taken Shankar(Director of “I” and Robot) or Farhan Akhtar(Don series) as the director. Cinematography is good though. One thing that stands out as the best part is Mithoon’s music. Its different stylish yet attractive. Hats off to Mithoon.

    I am going with a 3*. Expectations were sky high. Was ready with a 4* till Interval but later on it wasn’t that much good.

  • Shivaay
    It was epic but not for boxoffice at all
    It was Hollywood typical with Indian tarka in it ??
    Slow dark super action . Father daughter great relationship
    The movie was about daughter father relation in general ..the bound

    Shivaay will get mix to bad reviews and it will flop at the box office.
    But the movie was good and different

    Not a Diwali movie . It shud be sold at lower cost..with normal release date and without big movie and big weekend relese hype
    In that case. Will get good Reviews And appreciated by all and a success..
    Because indias critic never review the movie as a movie itself ..
    Review usually depends on release date . Star cast . Buzz going around current reiwer state of mind …etc

    if same movie and same release date today and Salman hero . This movie will get 5 star not even 4 . And Salman will be explained as ultimate star of all time .

    Shivaay went into different direction . Not suppose to go there..
    It’s not a Diwali movie

    Thank you Devgan. He took Bollywood for the first time to Hollywood level in a Bollywood style ?????
    Not a copy ..not wanna be

    Shivaay 4 star my for me

    Thumb up 1 Thumb down 2

  • Is it me who just realized this…that…indice has changed their wirter if this article…the was bit harsh on the movie..normally indicne sugarcoat their reviews…nice change indice..most honest review!!!..but not 3star worthy judging by the article

  • @Rocky

    1. Andaaz apna apna VS Suhaag
    2. Kyun ki Vs Garam Masala
    3. Blue vs MAMK
    In sabme dekhiti teri bhabi ki aukaat
    Madhuri ko hatade na lallu se, he will be Rajpal Yadav in 90s, tu saal hatane ki baat karta hai

  • @Indicine, a regular visitor of urs, please publish it
    @Rocky

    1. Andaaz apna apna VS Suhaag
    2. Kyun ki Vs Garam Masala
    3. Blue vs MAMK
    In sabme dekhiti teri bhabi ki aukaat
    Madhuri ko hatade na lallu se, he will be Rajpal Yadav in 90s, tu saal hatane ki baat karta hai

  • koyl devgan is not star anymore.h e doesn’t deserve any holidays.

    Why he is so desperate about himself.he had no money to even invest on Shivaay,so Eros International helped him and invested a huge amount to Shivaay movie.

    But Ajay’s direction ruined it.Eros didn’t even expected about it.

    Hence today JTHJ’S revenge fulfilled.now koyla will definitely feel how it hurts when someone will come and will ruin your hard work of your whole career.this is what you got for your sin did by clashing against JTHJ after convinced by lallu Khan.now you’ll regret it for your lifetime.

    now onwards koyla,hopefully you’re understand your aukat that you’re not a star.better release on your movie on non holiday because BIG HOLIDAYS is not for small stars like you.and finally you’ll retire in THIS DEEWALI too.this is what your final destination that KJO SIR made and HE’LL definitely will drag you to the road which is the right place where you can beg like a shameless.

  • Isn’t entertaining all the way through
    Every bollywood movies have some dull moments.
    Too long and somewhat illogical
    All bollywood movies are illogical in some sense.

  • Ajay devgan all past diwali release s hit or superhit
    2008 golmaal returns superhit crashed all 3 films
    2009 all the best hit crashed akshay and salman films both two films crashed
    2010 golmaal3 ajay first 100 crore club crashed akshay
    2012 son of sardaar hit 100 crire diwali

  • @suraj tum apne aapko indicineke regularvisiter bol rahe ho to yeh to jaante hi hoge ki indicine clearly told intheir article that bhai was aheadofeveryone in 90’s
    now uwill bark multistarrer then tell me only 5solo hit movis of makki til 2007
    #A BHAI FAN

  • Thanks to Bookmyshow. I had got a discount of rs. 125. Disappointed by Shivaaay. I had really hoped shivaay would thrash ADHM. All the good action scenes are shown in trailer.

  • Just returned from watching SHIVAAY…
    Good action sequences wd one tacky shootout…..rest of d mvie is just passable…..initial reaction is wat an awesome trailer and dn ds movie……clean hit

Leave a Comment