Shah Rukh Khan vs Akshay Kumar: Our Take

The box office clash between Shah Rukh Khan’s untitled film and Akshay Kumar’s Toilet Ek Prem Katha (Toilet:EPK) will be the talking point for the next few months.

On paper, it looks one-sided. The untitled romantic film has a much bigger star cast with one of the biggest crowd-pullers in the industry (SRK), one of the most popular female stars (Anushka Sharma), well-known director (Imtiaz Ali), big budget and the music is expected to be a strong point too (Imtiaz-Pritam).

With Toilet:EPK, Akshay is the only known face. The female lead has appeared in one film (Dum Laga Ke Haisha) and editor-turned-director Shree Narayan Singh directed 2012’s Yeh Jo Mohabbat Hai which noone watched.

Yet, it’ll be the SRK-Imtiaz film that has all to lose and very little to gain – because business will now be divided between two films and the biggie won’t be able to take full advantage of the 5-day extended weekend.

For ‘Toilet:EPK’, the calculated risk that the makers have taken could prove to be a tactical masterstroke.

Reasons:

  1. Medium budget: Much like ‘Rustom’ last year, Toilet:EPK has been made on a controlled budget. Recovery will not be difficult if it turns out to be a well-made film. The fact that the makers are willing to take on a big-film, could also be an indication that they are confident of the film they’ve made.
  2. Ramzan release averted: Toilet:EPK was previously scheduled to release three weeks before ‘Tubelight’ and a week before ‘Raabta’. There was very little breathing space for a content-driven film to grow and perform. More so since the audience is known to save-up money for a event Salman Khan film during EID. The Ramzan period, when the muslim section of the audience do not come out to watch films, has been avoided too.
  3. GST: The ‘Goods and Service Tax’ will come into effect from July 1 2017. It’s expected to bring down the all-India entertainment tax levels, so Toilet:EPK will benefit from this as compared to June 2 release.
  4. Clash-publicity: We have seen in the past that clashes can prove to be beneficial, especially for the smaller film. Both films will get almost equal media coverage.
  5. Swacch Bharat: Toilet:EPK is based on Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Swacch Bharat Abhiyaan, which is a popular social cause amongst the youth. It’s most talked about during the Independence Day period. The film could also get tax-exemption, which will give its business a big boost.

From SRK’s point of view, there are very few positives. It was one of the biggest weekends of the year. A solo release would’ve probably meant 125 crore plus in the first 5-day weekend itself. But now with screens and shows divided between two major films, the release circumstances will be very similar to the ‘Raees vs Kaabil’ clash.

The SRK-Imtiaz film will comprehensively win the first day and weekend, but since it’s a big film, it has to perform at a much high level throughout to become SRK’s first clean hit in nearly 3 years.

Advertisements

135 Comments

  • When the real megastars are busy topping their 300 crore domestic games, one is still struggling with 150 crore and BO clashes. That’s just not fair. Akki please reconsider the fate of our king if this clash happens.

  • Zuheeb
    March 28, 2017 at 2:13 pm
    and i had sarcastically used the word bad phase and some did bash me…that means even they accept this is not bad phase…well
    THANK YOU FOR ACCEPTING THE FACT THAT SRK HAS BEEN THE MOST CONSISTENT ACTOR BOLLYWOOD HAS EVER PRODUCED (:

    1992
    Dil Ashna Hain
    1.30
    Flop
    1992
    Deewana
    7.75
    Hit
    1992
    Raju Ban Gaya Gentleman
    3.75
    Average
    1992
    Chamatkar
    2.60
    Flop
    1993
    King uncle
    1.80
    Flop
    1993
    Maya Memsaab
    2.00
    Flop
    1993
    Baazigar
    7.75
    Hit
    1993
    Darr
    10.75
    Super Hit
    1994
    Anjaam
    4.80
    Flop
    1994
    Kabhi Haan Kabhi Naa
    2.70
    Hit
    1995
    Oh Darling Yeh Hain India
    2.00
    Flop
    1995
    Raam Jaane
    9.50
    Above Average
    1995
    Dilwali Dulhaniya Le Jaayenge
    61.00
    ATBB
    1995
    Karan Arjun
    29.00
    Blockbuster
    1995
    Trimurti
    10.25
    Flop
    1995
    Guddu
    2.20
    Flop
    1995
    Zamaana Deewana
    4.55
    Flop
    1996
    Chaahat
    5.00
    Flop
    1996
    English Babu Desi Mem
    3.50
    Flop
    1996
    Army
    5.00
    Average
    1997
    Pardes
    18.00
    Hit
    1997
    Koyla
    12.00
    Below Average
    1997
    Dil Toh Paagal Hain
    28.00
    Super Hit
    1997
    Yes Boss
    9.50
    Above Average
    1998
    Duplicate
    9.25
    Below Average
    1998
    Dil Se
    10.25
    Flop
    1998
    Kuch Kuch Hota Hai
    45.25
    ATBB
    1999
    Badshah
    14.00
    Below Average
    2000
    Gaja Gamini
    5.25
    Flop
    2000
    Mohabattien
    33.25
    Super Hit
    2000
    Phir Bhi Dil Hain Hindustani
    10.25
    Flop
    2000
    Hey Ram
    6.80
    Flop
    2000
    Josh
    20.00
    Above Average
    2001
    One 2 ka 4
    5.50
    Flop
    2001
    Asoka
    8.25
    Flop
    2001
    Kabhi Khushi kabhi Gham
    47.00
    Blockbuster
    2002
    Hum Tumhare Hain Sanam
    13.75
    Above Average
    2002
    Devdas
    32.50
    Hit
    2003
    Chalte Chalte
    16.00
    Hit
    2003
    Kal Ho Naa Ho
    35.00
    Hit
    2004
    Main Hoon Naa
    33.00
    Hit
    2004
    Yeh Lamhe Hain Judaai Ke
    4.50
    Flop
    2004
    Veer Zaara
    40.00
    Super Hit
    2004
    Sawdes
    15.25
    Flop
    2005
    Paheli
    13.00
    Flop
    2006
    Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna
    45.75
    Hit
    2006
    Don
    51.00
    Hit
    2007
    Chak De India
    67.75
    Blockbuster
    2007
    Om Shanti Om
    79.75
    Blockbuster
    2008
    Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi
    86.78
    Blockbuster
    2009
    Billu
    23.64
    Flop
    2010
    My Name is Khan
    75.00
    Hit
    2011
    Ra one
    120.00
    Hit
    2011
    Don 2
    115.00
    Hit
    2012
    Jab Tak Hain Jaan
    121.50
    Hit
    2013
    Chennai Express
    218.00
    Blockbuster
    2014
    Happy New Year
    203.00
    Super Hit
    2015
    Dilwale
    145.00
    Semi Hit
    2016
    Fan
    84.20
    Flop
    2016
    Dear Zindagi
    67.00
    Hit
    2017
    Raees

    According 2 u this is consistency?! LMAO…. then Abhishek is The biggest coz he has Dhoom brand.

  • both clashed with my favourite. ..so don’t know whom should I support. ..but one thing is for sure this akki is making producers losse their money. ..because whoever wins the other film is always at loss because akki’s movie budget is very less…I liked him earlier but started hating him since last few months. ..and the one reason for that is his brainless fans …@jolly and @deadpool….two loosers…

  • It is a myth that a SRK film never loses out in a clash. In 2001, his own production , Asoka, clashed with Indian (Sunny Deol). Indian completely beat the opposition and was the comfortable winner by huge margin.

  • Srk fans are waiting for tiger vs dutt clash????
    Aaj kal koi bhi aake bajake jata hai hamare king hakla khan ki…

  • what I sure about is that TBPK will be masterpiece film if not the best of the year and that all what we need it akkians so I happy that akki sir moves TBPK to 11 Aug 2017 and that to take his revenge for the dirty game that srk played during CE and OUATIMD clash

  • srk fans forget waqt hamara hai movie of akki has thrashed srk’s maya memshaab but this so called king fans will never mention this such a idiotic fans srk has ! he did very wrong with roshan family and karma is bitch take that srk you will still struggle for hit..

  • Shahrukh Khan is not a decade
    super star he is all times great
    that little average hero like
    Akshay and Haritak is all ways
    struggling through out there career
    they cannot complete with the
    undisputed king

  • Run away Shahrukh like u did with sultan.. Now nobody is afraid to take u on…slb, roshans n now akki.. going forward too even if u announce your movie on a particular date, still somebody will pick the same date and release his movie and its you who will have to either face the clash or run away..your time is over

  • i like both akki and srk and personally hope both of their films turns out to be clean hits which i am sure it will be good luck to these both self made superstars.

  • I have always said clashes on non holiday do not make any sense . This will be SRK’s 4th clash in this decade . Now I will put my money on TEPK . Akshay is having a terrific form with 2 Superhits and 2 Hits in the last 13 months . SRK is going through a dull phase since the last 3 years . Another important advantage for TEPK as it has been made on a reasonable budget so the recovery will be very easy . SRK – Imtiaz Ali film is looking expensive as it has been shot in Amsterdam, Prague, Lisbon and Budapest . TEPK is based on Swacch Bharat Abhiyan which is a very important issue especially among youngsters . This should appeal single screen audiences . There are high chances that it will get tax free status in BJP states such as Maharashtra, Gujarat, UP, Jharkhand, Goa, Manipur, Haryana, Rajasthan, Uttarakhand, MP, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh . This will give a huge boost to the lifetime collections . SRK has made some terrible choices in this decade such as Ra.One, JTHJ, Dilwale, HNY and Fan . On the other hand Akshay’s script sense has improved by leaps and bounds such as OMG, S26, Holiday, Baby, Airlift and Jolly LLB 2 . So this clash looks extremely interesting . This will be Akshay’s 4th Independence Day release in this decade after OUATIMD, Brothers and Rustom . If this clash happens it will be the 5th time between SRK and Akshay . !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Srk needs to avoid the clash!!according to you srk film will take a big opening!!BUT I BET TEPK WILL OPEN AT THE SAME LEVEL AS SRK S’ FILM!!MARK MY WORDS!!ull see!!the trailer and the songs of tepk will be fabb!!and at the end-AKSHAY KUMAR the big driving force in the film who is in such a marvelous form!!people will come out in hordes to watch his film!!

  • I love akki.. vut he is gonna lose money in overseas abd also tepk is not an universal film though I liked the subject and srk film is directed by imtiqz ali and the star cast is great.. and after 2 months of august robot 2 is also coming.. his fans can chose to skip this film..

  • Honestly, I didn’t know the releasing date of Toilet-epk. Now, everyone will know the releasing date of Toilet-epk. This move really benefit Akshay kumar’s film.

  • but i guess SRK will feel what felt for Bansali by Dilwale clash anouncement..
    Rakesh Roshan by Raees anouncement..

  • If SRK smart, move his movie to Eid,Dilw,Xms .
    Because he will clash anyway at least clash in biggest holidays better than clash in small holidays

  • Luck is now quite against SRK now a days…
    IF Raaes would have been the solo release during Eid ..it would have crossed 200..
    And tepk is releasing during Independence Day…& then So called Bhakts of this country will watch tepk for showing their patriotic nature…Whether they will like tepk or not but they will do promotion against srk’s film
    Bcoz ac.to many bhkts …srk is deshdrohi..
    So tepk will get advantage of that too..
    Poor SRK??

  • not to forget…Akshay was first to book Independence day 2017 for Crack and later SRK-Imtiaz booked the day even before Crack was officially postponed.

  • small budget? what is the package akshay takes home? what small budget how can you fool everybody in your articles!!

  • Patriotism and Modi-Yogi Bhakti
    These things sell nowadays.
    And perhaps akki wants to own Independence like Salman aamir own eid/xmas.
    Lets see

  • Patriotism and Modi-Yogi Bhakti
    These things sell nowadays.
    And perhaps akki wants to own Independence like Salman aamir own eid/xmas.
    Lets see

    Also this is gonna reduce the promotional and advertisement cost of TOILET bcoj it will get free publicity worldwide linked with SRK!!!

  • Toilet does not look like a film which will take an opening at the box office.. If jolly LLB 2 opened below the mark inspite of being a sequel then what will happen with this film..it will get a lot of publicity during its release but Akshay Kumar’s star power in these kind of films takes a beating..Add to that, he is clashing with shahrukh khan who took a film like Fan to 19 crore on day one..
    Imtiyaz ali films are known to have popular music, if this album turns out to be a chartbuster then even a 30% opening for Toilet on morning shows will be an uphill task..The lifetime results of srk films are not up to mark but his initial stardom just dosent seems to have taken a hit..he has already managed two 20 crore opening days with clashes on a non holiday, i expect this film to be his third..
    Regarding toilet, it will need a superb trailer and a strong backing from the promos and may be music also to open in double digits or else the makers should be happy if they manage to beat the figures of Kaabil on day one..
    All the best to both the sides

  • srk-imtiyaz film box office – 130cr to 140cr – Average
    TEPK box office – 60cr to 70cr – Average
    Tiger ka fan

  • @Zuheeb Bhaijaan go and get your facts right… Kaabil proved to be much liked and loved movie than Raees. Kaabil had an opening of 10.43 Cr not 7.5 Cr despite lesser screens 40% and not a masala movie (with mass appeal) like Raees. Despite that it was Kaabil which turned out to be better film and bigger HIT in every aspect (leave aside rave reviews of critics and moviegoers alike). SRK was looking like a dwarf against HR.

    SRK played dirty game with screen counts (60% screens) and could get initial advantage for 1st week but rest is history. Kaabil outstriped Raees in every subsequent weeks coz of it’s content and better packaging. If screen counts were 50-50 then Raess (with very high promos) wud have been folded under 16-17 Cr and Kaabil 14-15 Cr on opening day itself and lifetime for Kaabil would have been 160 Cr and Raees 110 Cr.

    SRK is a fading star now…he is failing continusouly in India and the fact is that (we all know)- SRK can never challenge Salman or Aamir in current times so he tries to clash with juniors that itself is a sign of defeat for SRK. SRK’s selection of movies are very poor- CE, Raess, HNY, Dilwale all have been bullshits on content part. Even people change their channels if these movies are aired on TV.

    Its tough time for SRK and Akki has delivered a hard punch now on SRK’s face.

Leave a Comment