Aamir vs Salman: Can Dangal beat Sultan?

The last highest grosser of the year (HGOTY) that did not feature Salman Khan or Aamir Khan in the lead, was Shah Rukh Khan’s ‘Om Shanti Om’ back in 2007.

In other words, for the last 8 consecutive years, Aamir or Salman have topped four years each – Ghajini (2008), 3 Idiots (2009), Dabangg (2010), Bodyguard (2011), Ek Tha Tiger (2012), Dhoom 3 (2013), PK (2014) and Bajrangi Bhaijaan (2015)!

With Sultan all set to touch the 300 crore mark, 2016 is likely to be yet another year when the battle will be between the Top 2 superstars for the ‘Highest Grosser of the Year’.

The other big releases of the year have practically no chance – because of clashes or unfavourable release periods – to get anywhere close to the total of ‘Sultan’.

While there is very little to differentiate between Salman and Aamir, there is one interesting point that shows Aamir has held the upper hand in the last few years.

Since 2008, each time Aamir had a release ready for Christmas, he has achieved the following:

  1. All his films have become the highest grosser of the year
  2. All his films have gone on to become the highest grosser of all time (a record that has eluded Salman for the last many years, inspite of his super stardom)
  3. All Aamir films have also crossed a major milestone - Ghajini was the first film to 100 crore, 3 Idiots first to 200, Dhoom 3 was the first to 250 and PK in 2014 became the first to go past 300.

With plenty of open weeks and the best release period of the year – the odds will be in Aamir’s favour once again. However, he doesn’t have a top director like Rajkumar Hirani or a major franchise like Dhoom this time around – much like Ghajini in 2008.

If Dangal tops, the gap between Aamir (6 career HGOTY) and Salman (9 career HGOTY) will reduce to 2. Otherwise, Salman will earn the 10th highest grosser of his career and the gap between him and the rest will be 4 films or more.

SalmanAamirSRKHrithikSunny
Maine Pyaar Kiya (1989)Dil (1990)DDLJ (1995)Kaho Na Pyaar Hai (2000)Border (1997)
Saajan (1991)Raja Hindustani (1996)Kuch Kuch Hota Hai (1998)Koi Mil Gaya (2003)Gadar (2001)
Hum Aapke Hain Kaun (1994)Ghajini (2008)Devdas (2002)Dhoom 2 (2006)
Hum Saath Saath Hain (1999)3 Idiots (2009)Veer Zaara (2004)
No Entry (2005)Dhoom 3 (2013)Om Shanti Om (2007)
Dabangg (2010)PK (2014)
Bodyguard (2011)
Ek Tha Tiger (2012)
Bajrangi Bhaijaan (2015)
Advertisements

177 Comments

  • @Indicine one request to you can u make a chart of sultans collection and update it once in a day untill its cross 300cr.
    Thnx.
    #sultan300cr

  • After Dangal Aamir and Salman both will have equal number of HGOTY (Even though Aamir has done way less films than salman and also Aamir had no releases in many years such as 2002,2003,2004,2010,2011,2015,etc) because no entry and saajan should not be credited to salman alone because he was in supporting role/cameo kind of roles in these 2 movies. Saajan was sanjay Dutton movie as he was the lead and no entry was a completely anil kapoor and fardeen khan movie with salman just having a cameo apearance. So Salman has 7 HGOTY and Aamir has 6 as of now. After Dangal both will have 7 each. Fair enough. Some salman fans who are barking about aamir without Raju HiranI and dhoom brand had talaash should not ignore bhai’s epic success trivia such as marigold, Main Aur Mrs khanna, yuvraaj, God tossing great ho, veer, jai ho, etc without Kabir khan, yrf, South remakes, holidays, etc. Case closed.

  • After Dangal Aamir and Salman both will have equal number of HGOTY (Even though Aamir has done way less films than salman and also Aamir had no releases in many years such as 2002,2003,2004,2010,2011,2015,etc) because no entry and saajan should not be credited to salman alone because he was in supporting role/cameo kind of roles in these 2 movies. Saajan was sanjay Dutton movie as he was the lead and no entry was a completely anil kapoor and fardeen khan movie with salman just having a cameo apearance. So Salman has 7 HGOTY and Aamir has 6 as of now. After Dangal both will have 7 each. Fair enough. Some salman fans who are barking about aamir without Raju HiranI and dhoom brand had talaash should not ignore bhai’s epic success trivia such as marigold, Main Aur Mrs khanna, yuvraaj, God tossing great ho, veer, jai ho, etc without Kabir khan, yrf, South remakes, holidays, etc. Case closed.

  • On Christmas if aamir releases his films then they will be ATBB ; but if our superstar of bhojpuri film industry Mr. CHUK CHUK KHAN dares to release his films it will be just an average film like BHANGARWALE.And people say that E toh hamre Sah ruk ka stardom wa. STARDOM MY FOOT. Even actors like Ranveer Singh bashed him on the box office.Now pls dont dare to clash ur Raess with Dangal varna uska bhi haal All Time Disasterous FAN ki tarah ho jaega aur phir aapke FANS bolenge ki E TOH HAMRE MIYABHAI KI DARING WA! ITs time for u to retire even from the Bhojpuri film industry. pls bas ab aur nahi seh sakte aapki STARDUM bhare torchurs .Box office aajkal haarne wale ko BHOJPURI BAAZIGAR kehte hain. Aree aapki film flop karane ke liye toh MOGLI hi kaafi hai.

  • King khan’s raees will break avatar records. Movie has got huge buzz on jupiter the largest planet of the solar system

  • Main reason of success of Amir Khan is Good Script/Director like 3I and PK/Big Brand like Dhoom plenty of Holidays including Christmas.All above movie got 2 Sunday Christmas Holiday 31st Dec partial Holiday and New year Holiday.Even script was also appreciated to audience accept D3.But This time amir will not get benifit of Christmas Holiday because Christmas fall on Sunday and new year also fall on sunday so 25cr of Christmas and 15cr of new year less from total.So even if movie appriciated like PK then 340cr can be possible but 40cr less mean 295 to 300cr which is lesser than Sultan..302/303Cr(expected).

  • @hrithik,itna khichta kyun hain.

    Shortly said

    AMIR SIR has—-6 hgoty(all solo starrer) in 28 years

    sallu has—-6hgoty(saajan,hssh multistarrer,no entry solo film) in 27 years

    KING SRK has—-5 HGOTY(all solo starrer) in just 24 YEARS

    ha ha ha ha.

    And salman is the one who struggled 16 years to get his own starrer hgoty(1994-2010)

    Not only that periods KHANS taken to give hgoty

    amir taken—-20 years(1998-2008)

    KING KHAN taken—-15 years(officially with OSO),or (1992-2013)—-21years

    sallu taken—-struggle maximum 22 years to give ATHG(1994-2016 continuing)—-ha ha ha ha ,see shameless aukatless decade struggler flopstar’s aukat,rofl.

    And CONSISTENCY means giving SUCCESS.your decade struggler struggled for a single starrer hit in whole last decade,if he is consistent for you,then have suicide with shame,rofl.

  • Here is My Prediction

    1. Sultan – 298-300* Cr
    2. Airlift – 127 Cr
    3. Dangal – 118 Cr
    4. Houseful3 – 107 Cr
    5. Mohenji Daro – 95 Cr

  • HaHaHa Those Who Always Complaining Aamir Khan is nothing without Hirani and Dhoom Franchies, are Lost thier Faith, Don’t u Guys Think See How Blindless and Jealous u are about This Legand Aamir khan, Iam not Against Like them, to Greate Masterpiece Director Sir Raj Kumar Hirani Or Franchies Prand Dhoom Series but, Seriously Guys Before Aamir khan’s Dhoom 3 released, How Much 2 Sequels of Dhoom Series movies both Compineing Collected at there Respected Boxoffice Released Years and How Much Before 3 Idiot and BK Come to Limelight Which Made 400cr and 800cr Worldwide Somewhere in 2009/2014, What was Raj Kumar Hirani’s Higest Worldwide, May Be Two Munna BAI MBSS Sequels, Which it Self collected Even not more than 100crs, so Iam Quite Sure This Chrismas in 2016 Even if Aamir’s DANGAL Grossed the Border Which I Expected as allways u will never admite the Truth about this Legand Aamir khan who is present and will be ever in near Future the Bollywoods Marketing Man to Challenge to the World Cinema

  • Well, this year, to be fair, everything is against Aamir.
    Boycott by 2-4 BJP maniacs, XMAS and New Year falling on Sunday and a movie that won’t appeal to each and every section of the country at least on the 1st day(trailer might change that). Also, the only pulling factor is Aamir. Actors are unknown(mostly debutantes) and the director is rather not known himself.
    .
    But, here comes the big revelation-
    Aamir himself in a press conference said that Dangal is like just another Raju Hirani film with the right blend of humour and emotions. Also, the movie focuses on girl empowerment and female infanticide with patriotism at its core. This itself would result in tax exemptions from at least the non BJP states like UP, Bihar, Delhi, Punjab and maybe Maharashtra.
    Now some stunning words from industry people:
    KOMAL NAHTA: I’ve heard the narration of Dangal and I must say, it is a brilliant scipt. Aamir’s sense of selecting scripts is out of the world. It has the potential of becoming the biggest hit of 2016. Women and families would go repeatedly to watch it.
    .
    PRITAM(Dangal’s music director): The film is not so dependent on music as the script itself is so powerful. I’m very excited for Dangal bcoz of Aamir.
    .
    Ali Abbas Zafar: Dangal will be the best film of the year, even better than Sultan. It is a story that has to be told.
    .
    Reportedly, Aamir rejected 200 scripts to finally select Dangal. He also gave 2 years of his life to it.
    If anything of this above is ti go by, we can expect a classic universal film in December that will definitely cross PK and might even do 375-400 cr. if the appreciation is close to 3 Idiots or even TZP.
    I’m going with Dangal to be the HGOTY despite everything being against Aamir due to the sheer reputation Aamir has build for himself.
    My prediction – HGOTY and a new 350 crore club shall be opened by about 10th January 2017.

  • Be like rajnikant if Amur and Salman wants to call them stars, he has release Kabali on non holiday with Bollywood clashes. Indicine stop manipulating us we know how sultan got this collection!

  • @sss if Salmans movies r multi starts den what is srk with out multi star??? All his super hit, blockbuster movies r multi stars except DDLJ, RBJ, CE

    KKHH-MULTISTAR
    KKKG-HUGE MULTISTAR
    DIL TOH PAGAL HAI-MULTI STAR
    MAIN HUN NA-MULTI STAR
    KANK-MULTI STAR
    DEVDAS-MULTISTAR
    KAL HO NA HO-MULTI STAR
    CHAK DE-MULTI STAR(ALTHOUGH SRK ONLY THE KNOWN FACE)
    OSO-MULTI STAR(WHOLE INDUSTRY)
    KARAN ARJUN-MULTI STAR

    DID I MISSED ANY BLUCK BLUSTER?????

    NOTE : MULTI STAR MEAN MOVIE WHICH HAVE MORE THAT ONE ACTREES OR STRONG SUPPORTING CAST…..

  • THE LIST IS QUIT LONG I FÔ?GOT TO ADD

    MOHABATTEIN – MULTISTAR
    VEERJAARA-MULTISTAR
    HAPPY NEW YEAR-MULTI STAR

  • Aamir was first actor to cross 100 cr .
    First to cross 200cr
    First to cross 300 cr .
    And he on the top list of highest grosser nw with ok

    And

    He will be the first actor to cross 400 cr ..

    He is the one who taught us what is do to business in 3 figures with 1 . 2 or 3 to be the first number in it

  • Aamir was first actor to cross 100 cr .
    First to cross 200cr
    First to cross 300 cr .
    And he on the top list of highest grosser OF ALL TIME .. RIGHT now with PK
    (CORRECTION)*

    And

    He will be the first actor to cross 400 cr ..

    He is the one who taught us what is do to business in 3 figures with 1 . 2 or 3 to be the first number in it

  • So what still with so many holidays sultan cannot beat Dilwale overseas collection that film came with Bollywood and Hollywood clashes. After all King is King !

  • As HGOTY is concerned then i believe that tingu sir will bcoz he has a great script sense and can also act well,not like lallu master.xmas is bigger than EID in INDIA and overseas,specially overseas markets will be great.I wish SRK to release RAEES on XMAS bcoz XMAS is bigger than 26th jan and his film could earn better even with a clash with DANGAL.Both their films will be good and people will watch both of their films,so need to worry,RAEES looks a great film.Tingu has a good script sense and can act,so his film DANGAL will also hav great collections.So nothing to loose SRK,WHEN EVERYTHING IS AT STAKE.It’s better to release RAEES on XMAS with DANGAL rather than releasing RAEES against KAABIL on 26th JAN on a small holiday weekend.It’s logic.

  • @hritik
    even if he is teesra khan, u the king of exclamation cant ignore him. This shows in itself his stardom and importance
    Insecure. Dont know if u are a salman fan or srk hater more

Leave a Comment