Aamir vs Salman: Can Dangal beat Sultan?

The last highest grosser of the year (HGOTY) that did not feature Salman Khan or Aamir Khan in the lead, was Shah Rukh Khan’s ‘Om Shanti Om’ back in 2007.

In other words, for the last 8 consecutive years, Aamir or Salman have topped four years each – Ghajini (2008), 3 Idiots (2009), Dabangg (2010), Bodyguard (2011), Ek Tha Tiger (2012), Dhoom 3 (2013), PK (2014) and Bajrangi Bhaijaan (2015)!

With Sultan all set to touch the 300 crore mark, 2016 is likely to be yet another year when the battle will be between the Top 2 superstars for the ‘Highest Grosser of the Year’.

The other big releases of the year have practically no chance – because of clashes or unfavourable release periods – to get anywhere close to the total of ‘Sultan’.

While there is very little to differentiate between Salman and Aamir, there is one interesting point that shows Aamir has held the upper hand in the last few years.

Since 2008, each time Aamir had a release ready for Christmas, he has achieved the following:

  1. All his films have become the highest grosser of the year
  2. All his films have gone on to become the highest grosser of all time (a record that has eluded Salman for the last many years, inspite of his super stardom)
  3. All Aamir films have also crossed a major milestone - Ghajini was the first film to 100 crore, 3 Idiots first to 200, Dhoom 3 was the first to 250 and PK in 2014 became the first to go past 300.

With plenty of open weeks and the best release period of the year – the odds will be in Aamir’s favour once again. However, he doesn’t have a top director like Rajkumar Hirani or a major franchise like Dhoom this time around – much like Ghajini in 2008.

If Dangal tops, the gap between Aamir (6 career HGOTY) and Salman (9 career HGOTY) will reduce to 2. Otherwise, Salman will earn the 10th highest grosser of his career and the gap between him and the rest will be 4 films or more.

SalmanAamirSRKHrithikSunny
Maine Pyaar Kiya (1989)Dil (1990)DDLJ (1995)Kaho Na Pyaar Hai (2000)Border (1997)
Saajan (1991)Raja Hindustani (1996)Kuch Kuch Hota Hai (1998)Koi Mil Gaya (2003)Gadar (2001)
Hum Aapke Hain Kaun (1994)Ghajini (2008)Devdas (2002)Dhoom 2 (2006)
Hum Saath Saath Hain (1999)3 Idiots (2009)Veer Zaara (2004)
No Entry (2005)Dhoom 3 (2013)Om Shanti Om (2007)
Dabangg (2010)PK (2014)
Bodyguard (2011)
Ek Tha Tiger (2012)
Bajrangi Bhaijaan (2015)
Advertisements

176 Comments

  • DANGAL will beat sultan.
    Even if Opening weekend 104cr and Monday 19 cr it will easily collect atleast 320cr…otherwise history will be repeated and DANGAL creats all time record in the history of bollywood cinema..my bet on DANGAL MIN-310cr(in worst case)
    Max-380cr(best case) wait n watch

  • If Dangal beats Sultan I will be happy as in last year 2015, Salman already had HGOTY with BB. If Sultan becomes HGOTY I will be more happier. Does not matter as far two Megastars compete with each other as Teesra Khan still chasing 227 crs and it is been 9 years since he gave a HGOTY !!!!!!!!!!

  • Just look at the consistency at which both have been delivering HGOTY, even in his Golden Time SRK was no where near this consitency.

    SRK :

    1995

    1998

    2002

    2004

    2007

    Aamir :

    1990

    1996

    2008

    2009

    2013

    2014

    Salman:

    1989

    1991

    1994

    1999

    2005

    2010

    2011

    2012

    2015

    Too much fun !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • We are more than happy that Sultan touching 300 Crores, which I had expected to go just over 270 Crores..

  • Mustn’t forget that this time Christmas and new year holidays are falling on Sundays. So two holidays lost. Could prove to be crucial when you’re chasing 300 crores

  • non actor’s some of the hgoty are completely multistarrer and no entry is not at all non actor’s movie,how it could be added?

    Amir sir is obviously will give hgoty of the year.because aftera all He is not a non actor like bhojpuri sallu.

    Still KING KHAN has 5 HGOTY of HIS own in just 24 years,while it and sallu took 28 and 27 years respectively,so not a big deal at all.

  • We are proud of Salman who was the first Highest Grosser of All Time among his generation actors, a record that took 7 years to be broken.
    He holds the record of the Highest All Time Grosser of 21st Century.

    Nonetheless, Aamir’s current records deserve huge applauds especially because he holds these records with minimum BO Figures manipulations.
    True records!
    Let’s say Dangal is another ATBB as of now

  • Amir makes or break records because of x-maths 3week free run.but this time no chance for amir to cross sultan.
    #sultan300cr

  • As for Dangal, realistically, this is another test for Aamir.

    Factors against:
    – This doesn’t have enough commercial appeals like Ghajini, 3 Idiots and Dhoom 3, Franchise Factor and Raju Hirani.
    – Based on the wrestling theme similar to Sultan
    – Aamir Intolerance Controversy

    Factors in favor:
    – Aamir himself, this man is unpredictable and has perfect sense of script and marketing
    – Nitesh Tiwari, whose previous film, – – Chillar Party was a masterpiece that won national award.
    – Women Empowerment theme
    – XMas with Plenty of Holidays

    All in all, I predict 250 Crores plus from it and if it crosses 300 Crores and beats Sultan, that should be phenomenal and awesome.

    Well, Clash of the Titans is on!!

  • @ 80 crore global king (chameleon) ,OSO also clashed with Saawariya in which salman have a small cameo. lol !!!

  • Some records of Bhai which really matter in terms of business, not just for the sake of creating records…
    — Three ATBBs or 8th Blockbusters in 7 years
    — Four back to back 200 Crores grossest
    — 10th Consecutive 100 Crores grossest
    — Hopefully, first actor to have 2 films in 300 Crores club.

  • @A.B. thanks dear. I wish Mohenjo daro becomes a huge blockbuster because hrithik is my 2nd favorite after megastar. It’s unfortunate that loser flop star gobar is clashing with hrithik’s most ambitious movie. Otherwise it had every chance to cross 300 cr. I still hope that despite clash and non holiday MD crosses 200 cr which will be a massive achievement as no other actor has achieved this before.

  • @ 80 crore global king, OSO also clashed with Saawariya in which salman Khan have a small cameo. lol !!!!

  • Now see @sss comments, he said Amir sir but few months back he mock Amir Khan as he wrote Amoor, Tingu and Mr.Perfakenist but now he calling Amir sir. Lol.. poor @sss

  • A true fan of an actor is one who respects all other actors.one who continuously abuses and disrespect of other actors is can’t be a true fan of that particular actor.

  • Can Dangal beat sultan? Yes it can..
    Will Dangal beat sultan? Time will tell..
    Odds are not really that much in favour of Aamir Khan..the biggest disadvantage is that the Christmas and new year holiday is falling on Sunday..Sultan had a very favourable release period. the advantage of those two big national holidays will be clearly missing and it will be felt in the long run too but there are two things which can overcome many such disadvantages and they are Aamir Khan’s superstardom and the trust that the movie going audience has in him…more importantly Dangal is his home production ..add to that he is also playing the lead in it..I simply cannot imagine Aamir Khan going wrong with this film…a lot has been discussed about the advantage of a dhoom brand and Raju hirani and I think it’s baseless to keep on reducing these external factors to measure a superstars box office clout..Dhoom brand needed a bigger star than the previous one..and even hirani needed a big superstar to take his own box office achievements a notch higher..let’s not get into a debate, let’s just wait for Christmas and it will be crystal clear to everyone what Aamir Khan can do when he is all alone…
    Regarding highest grosser of this year,my bet was, my bet is and my bet will always be an Aamir khan Christmas release simply because he is wise to enough to release a right film at the right time..he won’t release a dhobi ghat or a Talaash during Christmas..Expecting another 300 crore grosser from Mr. Perfectionist in the form of Dangal – My most awaited film of the year..All the best

  • @Sandy how about this? When he came without Kabir pappa, yrf, eid, diwali and Christmas then he came with Flop Ho. How much flop ho collected? Only 105 cr (real figure) with more ticket price than talaash? Oh is it? And flop ho released in 2014 while talaash released in 2012. Mark my words. Dangal will thrash sultan in pieces. Forget this small movie, aamir’s target is his own PK record. Mark my words and buzz off.

  • It’s lyk two bros r up against d other for d prize…
    my all tym fav aamir vs my 2nd fav Salman..so both deserve it..Bt since sultan didn’t open d 400 Cr club..hoping ki Bangalore becomes athg n opens 400 Cr club…
    fingers crossed… #aamir #salman #salmir

  • No issue who won d battle but if dangal beats Sultan den definitely it’s gonna a classic…… Hope to see another classic from MR AMIR

  • Aamir’s movies have a repeat value..
    he can pull this time around 400cr..
    so no comparision against him with non other.
    He took him self to 95kg…for just a 2hrs screen time.
    That shows the movies should cross 400cr

Leave a Comment