Aamir vs Salman: Can Dangal beat Sultan?

The last highest grosser of the year (HGOTY) that did not feature Salman Khan or Aamir Khan in the lead, was Shah Rukh Khan’s ‘Om Shanti Om’ back in 2007.

In other words, for the last 8 consecutive years, Aamir or Salman have topped four years each – Ghajini (2008), 3 Idiots (2009), Dabangg (2010), Bodyguard (2011), Ek Tha Tiger (2012), Dhoom 3 (2013), PK (2014) and Bajrangi Bhaijaan (2015)!

With Sultan all set to touch the 300 crore mark, 2016 is likely to be yet another year when the battle will be between the Top 2 superstars for the ‘Highest Grosser of the Year’.

The other big releases of the year have practically no chance – because of clashes or unfavourable release periods – to get anywhere close to the total of ‘Sultan’.

While there is very little to differentiate between Salman and Aamir, there is one interesting point that shows Aamir has held the upper hand in the last few years.

Since 2008, each time Aamir had a release ready for Christmas, he has achieved the following:

  1. All his films have become the highest grosser of the year
  2. All his films have gone on to become the highest grosser of all time (a record that has eluded Salman for the last many years, inspite of his super stardom)
  3. All Aamir films have also crossed a major milestone - Ghajini was the first film to 100 crore, 3 Idiots first to 200, Dhoom 3 was the first to 250 and PK in 2014 became the first to go past 300.

With plenty of open weeks and the best release period of the year – the odds will be in Aamir’s favour once again. However, he doesn’t have a top director like Rajkumar Hirani or a major franchise like Dhoom this time around – much like Ghajini in 2008.

If Dangal tops, the gap between Aamir (6 career HGOTY) and Salman (9 career HGOTY) will reduce to 2. Otherwise, Salman will earn the 10th highest grosser of his career and the gap between him and the rest will be 4 films or more.

SalmanAamirSRKHrithikSunny
Maine Pyaar Kiya (1989)Dil (1990)DDLJ (1995)Kaho Na Pyaar Hai (2000)Border (1997)
Saajan (1991)Raja Hindustani (1996)Kuch Kuch Hota Hai (1998)Koi Mil Gaya (2003)Gadar (2001)
Hum Aapke Hain Kaun (1994)Ghajini (2008)Devdas (2002)Dhoom 2 (2006)
Hum Saath Saath Hain (1999)3 Idiots (2009)Veer Zaara (2004)
No Entry (2005)Dhoom 3 (2013)Om Shanti Om (2007)
Dabangg (2010)PK (2014)
Bodyguard (2011)
Ek Tha Tiger (2012)
Bajrangi Bhaijaan (2015)
Advertisements

176 Comments

  • shocking news will come in next month raees prepone this year and it will be going to became hgoty ;)

  • Indicine…
    25th Dec and 1st Jan holidays are following on Sunday…
    Will it effect collection of Dangal…?

  • hence proved hritik is the only superstar after khans
    akshay kumar -error 404 not found
    now akki fans will say he do small budget movie ,3 movies per year
    huh tired of listening this excuse ,come up with some new excuses

  • Oh comeon Indicine, u not listing anil kapoor
    1. Beta 1992
    2. No entry(where sallu had hardly 30 min) 2005
    @Raj sharma
    going by ur logic anupam kher has hgoty too
    tezaab, dil, beta, ddlj, kkhh, veerzaara

  • aamir had great sctipt sense ,he is the only supetstar on which neutral audience can trust blindly
    bcoz his movies r damn awesome #respect from hritik fan

  • Srk stardome is nothing bt a bubble sustained on big banners. .. nevr achieved anything great lk salman n amir

  • Even though I am a srk fan, admitting that SRK is going downhill, I will go to watch Dangal twice. Aamir and Akki and also Hritik are also great great actors
    all the best mr. Perfectionist

  • Even 2007 may not have belonged duniya ka sabse chota star if Welcome and Taare Zameen Par hadn’t clashed. Otherwise it would have been Akshay or Aamir.

  • One of the co star of salman’s co-star Renuka Shahane views on black buck verdict

    In 1998 a Black Buck & 2 Chinkaras (that are endangered species & therefore cannot be killed) were allegedly killed on a hunting trip that included Salman Khan, Saif Ali Khan, Amrita Singh, Tabu & Sonali Bendre. Somehow while the ‘mor’ was ‘naaching’ in their ‘hivdas’ they wanted to shoot some endangered animals. And they did & ate them too. But did they? Out of all only Salman was charged for killing a black buck & a chinkara. He also served time for the same in Jodhpur jail. No charges were framed against the others. The case carried on & on & on as our cases do for two main reasons 1) Having big bucks (sometimes even blackbucks….different from the Black Buck who passed) or 2) Not having big bucks. Salman of course falls inthe 1st category of big bucks ( I don’t know their colour & we should not be racist by commenting) Sonow after 18 years he has been acquitted of chargesin both cases. Some questions come to mind 1) Who killed the Black Buck & the Chinkaras? 2) Did the driver kill them? 3) Did nobody kill them? 4) Do judges decide according to Buckworth-Lewismethod? ( What? Er…it’s Duckworth-Lewis?) Sorry! 4) Who will pay for the mental torture that Salman has had to go through now that he has been declared not guilty? 5) Doesn’t the nation want to know the truth? ( preferably very loudly) What? The nation doesnt want to know? No? Why? Oh you don’tsay…..busy spending bucks on Sultan….Er….then let it pass….yeah the Buck, what else? Dear, deer! Surreal!!!??

    by- Renuka

  • No worries for dangal…as sultan is a story of a romeo-wrestler..dangal can provide diffrnt xperience to the viewers..if it has entertainment like sultan then 300cr easily

  • in 1990-1995 its salman vs sunny
    in 1995 -2000 its salman vs srk
    in 2000-2005 its srk vs hrithik
    in 2005-2008 its akshay vs aamir
    in 2009-2016 its aamir vs salman
    top 2 stars of respective years and first one is the biggest and 2nd one is his closest compititeor ie both are no.1
    though i am salman fan but i accept in last 9 years amir has a little upper compared to salman.

  • 2 movies in 2016 for which i’m waiting for :-
    mohenjo daro and dangal
    REASONS:-
    1.) mohenjo daro —–> hr-ashu combo is the enough reason to watch mohenjodaro & after watching the trailer my expectations from action scenes of md increased very much and hritik never dissapoints when it comes to action be it krrish ,dhoom 2 or bang bang
    and i have full faith on ashutosh he is a great story teller yes a bit dissapoint by the vfx but its okay bcoz it dont have a budget like bahubali or robot 2
    2.)DANGAL —-> the reason is simple Aamir khan .He is master in making a normal movie amazing i have full faith on him and he never dissapoints .

  • V want andaz apna apna 2/ a movie featuring 2 mega khans…b4 they loses there grip @boxoffice becoz of ageing

  • Very nice To see that “die-hard”fans of sallu have changed side ( like the beast) and started praising aamir. .lol. …
    Dobi ka kutta na ghar ka na ghat ka

  • SRK did not give HGOTY after 2007.but he have both highest success ratio and hit ratio among khans or every actor .this shows he is the most consistent actor of Bollywood.

  • Without any brand …and without hirani sir ..he came .with…( talash ) and everybody know the result…!
    Now come to the point ..!
    1st point xmas fall on sunday …so it is very difficult to maintaine the pace of movie ..on weekday ..!! Weekend surly huge but after weekend ..no hirani / no big brand ..!
    So first week around 170 cr ..2nd week 60 cr third week 27 rest 20 cr ..! 277 cr maximum ..may be 285 cr ..!
    But mixed word of mouth ..first week 167 cr 2nd 52 cr third week 24 cr forth week end remaing week 15 cr ..!! Lifetime 258 -265 cr…!!
    But let see he is a Aamir ..everythink possible ..for him..!

  • Aamir Khan itself is a brand..
    He can pull up everything….
    Even 2001 should have been to him by Lagaan just missed.

  • Don’t worry Raees will beat every record if release date is good. so indicine has written clearly with clashes and without favourable release date one cannot have good collections. These other Khan are basically depend on good releases dates to become big stars what a shame .

Leave a Comment