PK vs Happy New Year: Box Office Collection Comparison

Aamir Khan’s PK and Shahrukh Khan’s Happy New Year were two of the most anticipated movies of 2014. While the former took a slow start at the box office on its opening day, Farah Khan’s Diwali release opened to packed houses across the country.

The comparison is interesting because both films had a similar release – PK had higher number of shows at multiplexes and also the average ticket price was about 10-12% higher. Happy New Year on the other hand, had two holidays in its first weekend (Sunday included), Saturday was also a holiday in parts of the country and it had a slightly wider single-screen release.

Interestingly, while Happy New Year went on to collect just 4.5 times its first day business (204.83 divided by 44.97 = 4.55), PK has already collected 4.37 times its first day collections (116.43 divided by 26.63 = 4.37). The Aamir Khan starrer, which is probably carrying the best word-of-mouth for any film released this year, could go on to do more than 10 times its first day business!

In 4 days, Happy New Year had collected 123.87 crore, while PK is trailing with collections of 116.43 crore.

DayHappy New YearPK
Day 144.97 (Diwali)26.63
Day 231.630.34
Day 332.29 (Sunday)38.24 (Sunday)
Day 415.0121.22
Day 513.1719.36
Day 611.0219.55
Day 79.5127.55
First Week157.57 cr182.89 crores
Day 85.2614.55
Day 97.4717.12
Day 109.51 (Sunday)
Day 113.31
Day 124.06 (holiday)
Day 132.75
Day 143.51 (holiday)
Two Week Total193.44 cr
Day 151.05
Day 161.8
Day 172.33
Day 180.9
Day 190.85
Day 200.73
Day 210.65
Three Week Total201.75 cr
Remaining weeks3.08 cr
Lifetime Collections204.83 cr214.52 crores (9 days)
Advertisements

63 Comments

  • no need to compare its obvious pk will beat hny and kick both and will be highest grosser of all time. watched pk it deserve to be attb.

  • @khan
    rohit shetty rescued ur kingz career his only blockbuster(ce) of recent times with gud wom and u r calling him shitty shame on u even other bgrade srk fans wil b ashamed of u
    and who is tiz dholakia and manish

  • @srk fan, at the time of hny release all of the srk fans challanged us tht it gonna collect more than 300cr but ur king movie did not surpass even 180cr(trade fig) mark.
    So, plz stop dreaming abou 300cr nd let ur king to giv 200cr grosser(nb- ce was a rohit/deepika movie more than srk).

  • @rijubasu intersteller collected 620million dollers… Katthi collected 180cr… Queen, haider also collected near 60 cr… How can u say these films struggled at b.o?

  • PK created history on Sunday by collecting the highest amount ever in one single day. The top five highest single days in his tory are as follows.
    1. PK (Sunday) – 37.75 crore apprx
    2. Happy New Year (Friday) – 36.37 crore
    3. Dhoom 3 (Sunday) – 33.89 crore
    4. Dhoom 3 (Friday) – 32.27 crore
    5. Singham Returns (Friday) – 31.68
    crore There are three other times when key benchmark of 30 crore nett has been crossed and that is the first day of Ek Tha Tiger and Chennai Express and also the second day of Dhoom 3. Dhoom 3 remains the only film to have crossed 30 crore nett three times, no other film has crossed it even twice.

  • rahul dholakia is the man who dare to create a film called parzania.
    And he is also an national award winning director.

  • IF YOU REALLY WANNA SEE PERFORMANCE, ACTING, CLASS MOVIE …. THEN WATCH PK…

    SUPERB PERFORMANCE BY AAMIR

    AAMIR SHOULD BE BEST ACTOR FOR 2014 !!!

    PK ROCKS !!!

  • rahul dholakia is the man who dare to create a film called parzania.
    and he is also an national award winner director.

  • U cannot compare HNY(garbage) with PK(masterpiece) HNY collected 200 only coz of SRK without him it would have struggled to even touch 40crs which 5 crores less den its opning day…
    PK will grow it has every chance to break Dhoom 3. I rember me calling pk a failure prior to its release but after watching PK I was like how can I comment so bad for such a wonderful movie. have already watched it twice.

  • Check your facts. Boxofficeindia gives lifetime figures of 180 cr. for HNY, so where did you get 204 cr. from? The first day figures of 44 cr. of HNY are grossly exaggerated. Its just 36 cr.

  • PK is way ahead than HNY and only 2 days of HNY can be compared with PK.HNY is not even a blockbuster while PK is heading for ATBB.

  • Even with negative ratings and bad reviews Hny earns 204 cr.Tees Maar Khan director is lucky that she gets a superhit this time

  • Pk is doing consistantly because of its Strong content, positive wom huge appreciation, presentation and Aamir’s award winning performance.

    HNY is not bad movie but lacks class which results mix wom.

    PK is really touching to peoples Heart but HNY is like “dekha, Haase aur Bhool gaye”

    But definately SRK has potentionlity, Hope he will deliver in 2015.

  • @akkil lokhande, than how did you watch Haider if you have not seen it in theatre? As I do not think it has released on TV. in which channel it was shown?

  • Christmas is Lucky for Aamir,if he release his movie on any other festive then sure he fails to deliver a superhit while SRK n SALMAN give several hits on non holiday also

  • @sidcinemafan
    in india intersteller is 8th highest grossing hollywood movie (very poor result for a masterpiece)
    gone girl is a washout.
    haider only manage to recover his costs and queen is managed to do well as per trade, but i dnt think 60 cr gross is a grt figure for any film nowdays.
    because bollywood craps are also heading for 200 – 300 cr total. hny collected rs 45 cr in a single day .and these good films need good worth of mouth grt reviews and lots of other things in their favour to deliver at BO.
    only kaththi do well because it stars thalapathy vijay as lead . if they cast any other good actor rather than him it will also crash at BO.
    i am a big fan of srk , but indian film-makers are not good enough these days or they just do projects and films are not an art form for them any more.
    as a true cinema lover i think its time to appreciate good works rather than these craps from the renowned actors and film makers.
    HNY , kick , singham returns , bang bnag , PK these are the top 5 grossing movies of india in 2014. this list tells u the story i think. they all are craps and repetitive .

  • Art in any form is always around the world served not only as entertainment, has been training, taught the good, develop a taste, the concept of beauty, etc. In India, where the majority of the population not quite competently, (illiterate) , film has a particularly strong impact for a huge segment of the population. Figures of cinema idols, they imitate. Filmmakers need to understand the responsibility for the fact that they carry to the masses ..
    But the films in India are recognized only at the box office, not in content, talent artist, etc. Put in a porn movie rentals – is unprecedented huge box office!
    This confirms the film 3Idiota “perfectionist, honor and conscience of the nation” Aamir Khan.
    The film raised important issues for young people, the dictates of parents to choose the profession of children, the structure of their entire life, against the system of training and beyond. Under the guise of relevant topics for Aamir hype for the film used a natural interest in the 16-20 years for everything that is related to sexual relationships, win-win situation.
    Vulgar scenes of initiation into the students, toilet humor, display a poster of the structure of women’s bodies, making childbirth – showed all that other actors would be ashamed to do …
    Speech meeting- beaten welcome new in-degree of disgust spoken.
    Frames with spermatazoidamiiz filmaThe beginning of a film “Look Who’s Talking” (Eng. Look Who’s Talking) – movie, filmed in 1989, directed by Amy Heckerling. Starring John Travolta, Kirstie
    Abstruse explanation of the mechanism – also from the film, I can not find the exact name.
    “3Idiota” is considered a hallmark AamiraKhana, and if you believe the words of the writer Ekzepyuri “One sees in the life that is in itself” Now imagine that within this perfectionist, honor and conscience of the nation.
    If you remove all of the obscene film, served as “a terrific sense of humor AamirKhana” young people will not go to the movie !!! Most decent about this humor can say – this is an American humor-pants fell -Funny fell, exposing something – to laugh hiccups.
    Figures from the film business (all judgments about the quality of the film, which the cashier did), critics do not understand that young people in 2-3 years will come into the community, and will behave like his idol – can conflict with the law, to pay off the money and live well, and you can need to dissemble, to expose and insulting former friends for their moments of glory, etc.
    I think that the film 3Idiota – harmful to young people, the shame of India

  • Srk fans before PK release :

    Talaash 2 or Dhobi Ghat returns

    After PK release :

    PK success is due to Hirani, Aamir is nothing.

    If Hirani is best why did your idol Srk refused his two movies ? Srk likes Farah more than Hirani. Whats the Aamir fault in it ????

  • @riju basu u r nothing but yet another pseudo intellectual who cn b seen posting rubbish comments in social media.u found pk avg and queen despite being a superhit u dont want to consider it much of a success.and u find all the big hits as craps.
    I don’t want to give a counter argument to ur stupid points bcz whenever I give logical counter to pseudo intellectuals like u I end up screwing myself.I hd tried my level best to maje pseudo intellectuals like @megha @slash to write some sensible stuff but I end up making myself senseless.so from now on I m going to ignore all ur comments and I request others to also do the same.

    thank u

  • @ARJUN KAPOOR FAN

    you missed the whole point. If SRK makes BAAZIGAR 2 today & release it at same time as CE, he will cross 225 crores. Rohit shitty and Farah khan got to him first despite being worst directors than Abbas – Mustan.

    Point is SRK is missing out on memorable films having repeat value like Aamir. Even salman has dabangg and wanted that has descent repeat value.

  • @khan just like u found d3,ce,hny to b garbage I found baazigar,raja Hindustani to b absolute garbage.and wat makes u think ce,hny aren’t memorable films?ce is literally shown every weekend on tv and almost everyone I hv met hv praised that movie.hny hs more of a mixed wom but still very positive.if hny,ce d3 r garbage then baaxigar,raja Hindustani r also garbage

  • @arjun kapoor fan,I don’t know which type of film watcher you’re?in no way BAAZIGAR can be compared with with these CE/HNY or craps like d3 neither with DDLJ and nor with raja Hindustani.it is far above than all those films,a negative role which non of a single superstar of whole country dare to do still KING KHAN did it at 90’swhiwhich not all accepted at that time still IT was a SUPER HIT.it also gave KING KHAN Filmfare best via in award.still you’re saying it a crap?if BAAZIGAR is crap than pk/ 3i are super craps ,this time you crossed the limit ,if BAAZIGAR is a crap then why all actor till today codn’t act in such a film?why this type of movie can’t repeat even twice?did you have any answer,I think no because your amir has no guts.

  • No comparison. HNY had many factors in favour like multistarcast, biggest heroine of current time, biggest holiday of new year and huge promotions to beg the audience and masala genre, so it had nothing to do with shahrukh’s star power. while PK released on normal working day when there are schools and colleges and businesses open, no big heroine like deepika, no masala genre, no aggressive promotions to beg the audience and still opened with 26 crs which is huge and third day broke all records and 4th day also much bigger than CNY’s 4th day/ lifetime record of CNY will be broken by the second weekend. poor srk and his 0 IQ fans. dhoom 3 with much lesser screens than Crappy New Year, nonholiday opened with bang and collected 36 crs which is much>>>>>>>than CNY which released on the biggest holiday. so aamir’s star power is way more than srk. no excuses. lets wait n watch his fan will bring in his real so called star power which has no deepika, no big director like rohit and will release on non holiday. I can bet it will open below 20 crs.

    aamir rox. srk sucks.

  • @sss u r truly an idiot.look at my cmnt againt.I said to riju and khan that if d3 ce r garbage then d same cn b said about baazigar,raja Hindustani also.

    bfr reacting u shd first read d comments carefully

  • lmao, tell ur king khan to release a movie with just teaser, no action, or catchy songs, or skin showing actress on non holiday instead waitin for full fledge diwali after release where every single person in india is off…then come n talk bout star power, n reason pk is working is more bcos of aamir actin not raju direction, everyone sain dats raju’s worst out of da 4movies he made recently….while others doing concert n goin to every popular tv shows…. he’s stand alone thy he’s name enough to bring audience…

  • while others sell products with catchy items songs, whueva popular at time using dem in like honey sings , n catch trailer n heavy promotions Aamir just do according to subject….till date have anyone seen aamir use Rajni, items, or honey sing to get a blockbuster opening…dose who braggin king power dis powers shows da insecurity one have…puttin anythin n everythin to sell da weekend…and in 90’s if Aamir wud’ve done yash chopra, aditya chopra, karan johar or rajshree we def wudn’t b talkin bout anyone with Aamir… where he is today, he came one he’s own with movie like lagaan, sarfarosh, tzp, n now pk….movie like ghajini n dhoom 3…any idiots wud know will break records cos it has masala garbage n feel good products….

Leave a Comment