Haider Review

Acclaimed filmmaker Vishal Bhardwaj returns to direct Haider, the third instalment of his Shakespeare trilogy after Maqbool (2003) and Omkara (2006). The film starring Shahid Kapoor, Tabu and Shraddha Kapoor is a modern-day adaptation of William Shakespeare’s Hamlet. Set in the beautiful Kashmir valley, Haider promises to be one of the best films of 2014. Does it live up to the immensely high expectations that comes with every Bhardwaj film? More importantly, will the filmmaker finally get commercial success? Let’s find out.

Story: Haider (Shahid Kapoor) returns to his hometown after he receives news that his father is missing. After returning home, Haider gets to know that his father has been abducted by the security forces and his mother Ghazala (Tabu) shares a relationship with his chacha Khurram (Kay Kay Menon). On a mission to find out the whereabouts of his missing father, Haider takes a journey that is filled with deceit, betrayal, pain and revenge. His only solace is his fiance Arshiya (Shraddha Kapoor).

Review: Shakespeare’s longest play Hamlet is widely regarded as one of his best works, a powerful story that has been adapted and retold by several filmmakers over the years. He captured human emotions like no other writer, which is why his plays have an evergreen quality about them even today, centuries after his death. When the film was first announced, it immediately generated quite a bit of curiosity. After successfully adapting Shakespeare’s Macbeth (Maqbool) and Othello (Omkara), how would Bhardwaj adapt a story as complex and layered as Hamlet to suit Indian sensibilities? How would he handle the sexual tension between Haider and his mother Ghazala? Thankfully, Bhardwaj not only gets it right with Haider, but delivers a film that will be remembered for years as one of the best adaptions of a Shakerspeare play to be made in the country.

Haider is made for those who love cinema, not the typical melodrama-filled or over-the-top masala movie lovers, but for those who have the patience and appetite for films that require you to be completely involved. Forget a loo-break, Haider is a film that requires your complete attention and understanding throughout. Cinematography is top notch and the soundtrack works well goes well with the film.

Like every other film, Haider has its own share of problems. Understanding the language can sometimes be a problem unless you understand Urdu. The pace tends to dip quite considerably at times and the film feels much longer than its runtime.

Coming to the performances, if you happened to walk in expecting Shahid Kapoor to deliver the performance of his career, you won’t be disappointed. He handles the toughest role of his career like a seasoned actor and by the time the closing credits roll, you can’t imagine any other actor in the industry nailing the character of Haider like Shahid has. Both Kay Kay Menon and Tabu leave a lasting impact on the audience. Menon is outstanding and Tabu deliveres a heart-wrenching performance, an act that will make you cry. Shraddha Kapoor does her best, she looks beautiful and acts well.. but expecting her to match-up to the onscreen histrionics of the other actors in a role that doesn’t really demand much, isn’t fair.

Overall, Haider is Vishal Bhardwaj’s best and by far the best of 2014 after Queen. But the response it gets will be mixed as Haider is not something that everyone will enjoy watching.

At the box office, Haider is expected to take a good start. But the business of the film will be affected by Bang Bang, which is sad because Haider deserved a solo release and complete attention of the audience. Releasing with a more mass-pleasing and audience-friendly film like Bang Bang is suicidal, but for the film that Bhardwaj has made, we hope it does well enough to be perceived as a success.

Rating: ★★★★☆

Advertisements

59 Comments

  • @arjun kapoor what r u saying ?? Fanny had no starpower. Shahid kapoor is better than ur oveshadowed kapoor. Haider will do double business of fanny. Shahid is 100 times better than ur whole crap youngistaan team. Shahid is fabulous actor.

  • @arjun kapur haider will do double business of fanny. Shahid is 15th spot acc to list. But haider will do more biz than 7th rank ranveer sing’s crap kill dill and 12th rank overshadowed kapoor’s fanny.

  • @indicine plz post ur review about bang bang. i dont believe in shits like taran adarsh who gave kick 4.5 bang bang 3.5 and haider 2 stars.

  • #Haider Getting 5 Stars by Critics ~ Raja Sen (Rediff) – 5/5 Jeeturaj Radio Mirchi – 5/5 Subhash K Jha – 5/5 Go Watch This Masterpiece!

  • @arjun kapur why r u underestimating haider biz ?? It wouldnt be difficult for haider to become a hit. Deepika overshadowed kapur <>> whole youngistan.
    Kill dill flop. Tevar flop. Haider hit.

  • @arjun kapoor you please go & watch Fanny & Aurengzeb. the great ‘cult disasters’.
    @punk you please ‘Jadoo’ yourself .. I never said anything bad about ‘Bong Bong’ you butthurt ‘Patang Fan’.. your comments show your insecurity.

  • @ punk even i havent seen guzarish and i love salman but i prefer old hindi movies over newmovies always i am salman fan but i am not his spoon. i beleive in my mind and its all about taste. salman dnt like guzaarish its his own choice cuz he dnt like that movie. i never believed what media consider i beleive in what my heart says to me. i can like classsical pyasa 1959 and i like also dehli belly kind of movie. now everything is clear.

  • Haider’s occupancy is low in the morning shows whereas Bang Bang has started with the bang.. Get ready for a massive 1st day box office collections. It should cross 30cr.

  • @ Indicine…i am very excitingly waiting for reviews of Bang Bang…and its first day collections…with 4300 screens …i am sure that it can cross 38 cr today..if Singham returns can collect 32 cr from 3600 screens with less hype than Bang Bang..than why not Bang Bang which has best hype for a movie till date…38 cr min is sure…

    if it collects 38 cr today..than without any doubt i can say it can collect 250 crs in its first 15 days of business….

  • Some morons are giving negatives talks about Bang Bang in twitter,fb n other portals without even interval of first show not completing….

    A review can be only given after 3.00 PM today for this movie. Prior to that any review is fake….

  • I am a big HR & Aamir fan..but it is unfortunate that i m missing the first day first show of bang bang due to other commitments….Will watch it tomorrow first show in morning…Meanwhile ….i hope Bang Bang get good reviews and make 38-40 cr collection today…

  • HAIDER IS GETTING BRILANT REVIEWS AND GOOD OPENING WHILE BANG BANG IS GETIND GOOD TO AVARAGE REVIEWS AND EXTRAORDINARY OPENING (BEST IN MULTIPLEXES FOR 2014 SO FAR)

  • in sha Allah it wil b a hit along wid bang bang
    ma prediction..
    bang bang lifetime 250+crores Atbb n hrithiks biggest grosser
    haider Around 70 crs hit n shahids highest grosser
    foh first day I guess haider wil do around 7 crs n bang bang 30-35 crs.. which means first day total wil b d biggest in bollywood on a single day… 37-42 crs… #skyisthelimit

  • @zeeshan u are a ‘lungi fan’ of your stammering actor. Hypocrisy is trademark of you khan fans. Haider is a good film but it did a huge mistake clashing with Bang bang. It could ve released solo. Haider will fail miserably due to the huge response to Bang bang. Indicine is telling the truth. You should worry about ur coming diwali flop.

  • Just watched bang bang here in Wave Noida- It was a feel good movie.Action has exceeded Dhoom series. Hrithik qas simply incredible. Story was okay-okay.Overall my rating -4/5

  • Now i will go for it before bang bang.. I will watch it tomorrow morning show.. Already postpone bang bang for sunday..

  • just watched haider OMG what a classic this is called movie shahid,s performance is incredible i never seen this type of brillian acting he is just insane total speechless a i m going to watch this movie again for shahid after shahid it was tabu oh what a brilliant acting she steals the show in the climax shraddha was also natural and give good performance where as music was also good so yes 5/5.nothing is bad about this movie.Haider deserves success at any cost.

  • just came back from watching haider

    don’t know how to write a review for a movie which is more than perfect in every department you include in a review
    story, acting, direction, screenplay, cinematography ,background music everything is beyond perfection

    special mention to a scene in which shahid kapoor acts as a mad person and gives a performance amid a crowd. just brilliant. i wont be surprised if shahid kapoor sweeps all best actor awards this year.
    tabu, k k menon, irfan & shraddha kapoor (in small roles) all are fabulous in their respective characters. the short guy who played salman was also brilliant.

    every scene every location is so beautiful that even blinking is a crime(as said by mohar basu in her review)
    again a special mention to the way bismil, aayo na and khul kabhi to were picturized. you are bound to be mesmerized

    but still some people may not like the movie due to a bit slow pace and depressing tone.
    also the movie portrays the indian army in a grey shade(although in the end credit india army is saluted for its efforts during j&k floods ) and kashmir freedom movement forms an integral part of the movie which may not go down very well with a section of people.

    rating – as i said this movie is perfect in every department you can speak of and should not be missed at any cost .
    i know most will prefer bang bang over this and as hny also arrives in the same month, this movie will suffer as many may not afford three movie outings in a month but if you are a true cinema lover don’t miss the opportunity to catch this masterpiece on the big screen.

    going to watch bang bang tomorrow. will post my views on that tomorrow at the earliest.

  • Megastar Amitabh Bachchan recently watched Vishal Bharadwaj’s latest directorial “Haider” and has only good words to say about the adaptation of William Shakespeare’s “Hamlet”.

    “This is a unique adaptation from Shakespeare’s ‘Hamlet’, and a film which is quite special. The entire mounting and the locations on Kashmir, where it is located, has been captured by some excellent photography,” he posted on his official blog srbachchan.tumblr.com Wednesday.

    He also lauded the performance of the cast, led by Shahid Kapoor and Shraddha Kapoor, saying: “And the performances of each and every one is simply extraordinary.”

  • Haider is only for those who are hungry for good cinema. Those who liked omkara , Maqbool , kaminey , gangs of wasseypur , Dev D are going to love this movie. This is creativity at its best. I think director like Vishal Bhardwaj should direct movies in Hollywood as there are very few people in India who understands and loves good cinema. Here everybody wants to see Kick , Bang bang and Dhoom 3. Kudos to Vishal Sir for giving us so many master pieces. We love you Vishal Sir.

Leave a Comment