Bollywood criticises Aamir Khan over ‘unsafe and intolerant India’

Aamir Khan’s comments on his wife wanting to leave intolerant and unsafe India, has been criticised by the industry.  The film fraternity, including actors like Anupam Kher, Ram Gopal Varma, Rishi Kapoor and several others have said that the actor must spread hope and not fear.

Aamir’s statement that his wife Kiran Rao feared for their son’s safety and that she once asked if they should be considering leaving India, is what has received severe criticism.

Ram Gopal Varma tweeted “If Aamir, Shahrukh and Salman the three biggest stars of the Hindu country “India” are Muslims, I don’t understand where intolerance is? In a predominantly Hindu country, if 3 Muslims can become the biggest iconic super stars that itself proves the majority aren’t intolerant. Some celebs complaining about Intolerance should be the last ones to complain because they became celebs in a so called intolerant country”

Ramu went on to add that isolated incidents shouldn’t be taken as a sign of intolerance.

“Isolated incidents can’t be taken as sign of intolerance and the super stardom of 3 Muslims is proof enough of the vast majority’s tolerance. It’s the celebs need for creating drawing room debates to increase their popularity which flares up non existent negativity between communities. If u are really feeling like a family and there’s a problem in the family, family members in public wont say there’s intolerance in the family. The fact is that the vast majority connect only to individuals deeds and generalised hard feelings are nothing but juvenile noises”

“Compared to any country India is the most tolerant and if some people are unhappy here also they should tell which country they will go to” RGV added.

Actor Paresh Rawal, who starred in “OMG: Oh My God!” which questioned the existence of blind faith in godmen, “Intolerance !PK did rattle the belief of Hindus but Aamir didn’t face the wrath of Hindu or THE MAJORITY, but was super hit n made crores !”

“Aamir is a fighter so he should not leave but change the situation in the country ! jeena yahan marna yahan ! A true patriot will not run away n leave his motherland behind in turmoil or in troubled times (if any )…don’t escape – build it.. If I believe this is my motherland then I will never talk about leaving it ….but I would if I had believed otherwise …” Paresh added.

Censor board chief Ashoke Pandit made a sarcastic remark, saying: “Now that @aamir_khan also feels we are an #IntolerantNation. Let us now go all out and prove once for all that we are really intolerant. Kiran Rao led MAMI (film festival) where India and Indian cinema were celebrated. @aamir_khan is himself a superstar loved and celebrated pan-India. Where is the intolerance?”

Rishi Kapoor had a advise for Aamir and his wife “Mr.&Mrs. Amir Khan. When things are going wrong and the system needs correction, repair it, mend it. Don’t run away from it. That is Heroism!”

Trade analyst Amod Mehra said “#Bajrangi Bhaijaan.. aap ke jigri dost ka KHANdaan is feeling insecure.. Toh aap ka FARZ banta hai ke unko border ke us paar chodke aana !!”

There was few names who supported Aamir — music composer Vishal Dadlani of the Vishal-Shekhar duo.

Dadlani said “More power to your voice, @aamir_khan Sir! This is OUR country, it belongs to ALL Indians. Not to rabid lunatics from any party/religion. Thanks to Aamir Sir, for speaking against intolerance! Proud to see the giants of film, use their voices for India.”

Aamir Khan is the brand ambassador of ‘Incredible India’, a campaign by the ruling government, which promotes Indian tourism outside the country.

Advertisements

120 Comments

  • Anupam Kher and Paresh Rawal are running for the seat of next PM of India. They Do Chamchagiri for BJP.

    In today’s time Bjp means a religion for Dump people like Kher and Paresh. Aamir or Srks statement about Politicians like Dhongi Adityanath, Sakhshi Maharaja, Shadhvi Niranjana, Vijayvargiya, Khatter, Shadhvi Parachi, Subhramanyam Swami, and religious groups like Hindu Sena, Ram Sena, Hindu Mahasabha, RSS, VHP, Bajrang Dal.Not for whole Indians or Hindus.

  • Out of all the tweets the best one was by Ram Gopal Verma . I am shocked he made such a mature and brilliant comment . No person says his family is intolerant and India is my family . India is a Democratic country and the constitution of India gives the right to freedom of speech . But that does not mean we should make statements that offend the feelings of common people . Aamir has gained immense respect for his movies, acting, social causes and hardwork but because of such statements people will question his loyalty . I do not like to talk about political issue since they are not my cup of tea but i strongly feel this is a conspiracy to defame the ruling party by showing them non secular and narrow minded . I am not saying everything is fine in India there are a lot of problems but these have been for a long time such as Poverty, Corruption, Cleanliness, Employment, Hoarding of goods and terrorism but still India as a whole is united and very few people are involved in such kind of activities . In 1984 Riots took place in Punjab, In 1993 Riots took place in Mumbai, In the same year Serial Bomb Blasts happened in Mumbai and in 2008 in Mumbai 26/11 Attacks took place . All such incidents have been much bigger and dangerous than the current situation . So the perception that only the ruling party is responsible for this is completely false . Another sensible tweet which i read on this topic was written by Chetan Bhagat . He said if a Muslim Terrorist kills a person we cannot call all the Muslims terrorists . In the same way if there are untoward incidents happening in India we cannot call India as a whole as Intolerant . Apart from Aamir Kiran Rao has made a childish comment . She is a educated and a responsible Indian citizen and we do not expect such words from her . She needs to understand that she is the wife of a superstar and whatever she says or not will be highlighted in the most huge manner .

  • Mr & Mrs amir u both shud be ashamed of urselves.Go and hang urselves!!!!Jis thali mein khaya usi mein ched!!!!All amir fans will dislike my comment still let me tell u all fans Desh se badhkar koi nahi hota.Where was amir during 26/11.Why he didn’t feel unsafe at tht time.Amir go in other country nd live there u will know wht india is!!!!

  • Aamir put forward the PoV of a common man, which I don’t find wrong!
    Ask yourselves everyone, ask your families, ask your mothers and sisters, do you feel 100% safe when you go out of your house? Do you feel safe sending women of your house late in the evening? Isn’t crime rising by the day?
    Isn’t this all a propaganda of intolerance?

    I fully stand with what Aamir said! Hota hai jo karle

  • @navin
    We r tolerating you
    So where is intolerance
    Salman didn’t say anything about intolerance
    But shame on srk and Aamir
    They became celebrities in hindustan and now they are degrading nation image
    Shame on people like you for supporting such a cheap actors

  • The Anupam kher and Paresh Rawal tweet doesn’t matters for me as both are connected to ruling party but I liked Paresh ji tweet that Aamir should start attending awards for protest. It was funny. Rishi ji tweets are the best, And RGV opinion hardly matters for me. But yes the most of people didn’t liked Aamir’s opinion including me. I hope it give lesson to Aamir so that he can express his opinion in balanced manner rather than exaggerated manner.

  • I agree with AAMIRs Statement.
    I would be more HAPPY if AAMIR would have said his REPLY to his WIFE.
    But again I would say This was trap by Indian media.
    He was on Right track when He was talking about TERRORISM & ISIS but then Media asked him about Intolerance.& He said “That’s a disastrous and big statement for Kiran to make”.
    Even He didnt Support CONGRESS also He said
    “What happened in ‘84 was disastrous and horrendous. At other times also, through ages, whenever there is a violent act, when an innocent person is killed, be it one or a large no.,that’s very unfortunate.”
    But Before Targeting Aamir,
    You should Know that,
    He made movies like ‘SARFAROSH,RDB,LAGAAN’ etc.
    Except govt of INDIA ads He rarely does any govt ads.
    He is the only actor who Shared the stages with SOCIAL ACTIVISTS including ANNA HAJARE.
    He SUPPORTED KASHMIRI PANDIT also.
    He was the only CELEBRITY to RAJECT the offer from MADAME
    TUSSAUDA.
    An actor who doesnt attend AWARD FUNCTION for Publicity, He is the only Celebrity who has shown his support for
    Narmada Bachao Andolan.
    He postponed TALAASH due to SATYAMEV JAYATE & TALAASH is his only SEMI-HIT movie in last 10 year.

  • Veteran Gulzar Saab also made comment on intolerance. Did anyone question on his religion or patriotism???

    More than 30 film makers have returned their awards for increasing intolerance. Is anybody questioning their religions???

    Then why all the morons are questioning on Aamir’s religion???

  • ha ha ha.. I’ve never said what Aamir said was right but that it was his right to express his opinions. Now, there are many that have come out of their holes to milk out of this opportunity and take the situation in their favor. Even more disgusting!!!

    @Indicine, why can’t you leave this topic? Oh I see, this issue is helping you to get more Hits on your site and articles, isn’t it? Dirty!
    Film fraternity, RGV, Anupam, Paresh??? Now, even RGV who has insulted will Hindu Gods on twitter may look a saint to you, won’t he?
    RGV, you pedophile? India- Hindu country? You are proving both Aamir an SRK, right? What about Sikhs, Muslims and Christians?
    Amod Mehra, you suck very badly, No words!

    Paresh Rawal, hats off to you! Such a balanced statement! Go on!

  • @indicine:You missed Raveena Tandon’s tweets..She has posted a series of tweets too.

    And she has also posted a TOI news paper click which reads,there were fewer communal clashes compared to previous years.

  • Whoever is feeling unsafe in India unko Middle East bhej do. Peaceful, Tolerant place. LOL
    If its wrong to tag your religion(The so called religion of Peace) with Terrorism which is directly associated with global terrorism, then why call our country intolerant because of some stray murder. Hypocrite Khans. One supports a terrorists, other two utter bullshits about India being Intolerant. Chhod na hai to chhod do na, media me aake bakwas karke desh ko divide karne ki kya zarurat hai. You scums need India, india doesn’t need you. You may get lost.

  • Who r saying that They made AAMIR they r IDIOTS.
    He is AAMIR KHAN coz of HIS ‘HARD WORK,COMMITMENT,SINCERITY & most importantly TALENT’
    Why they didnt make UDAY CHOPRA,TUSHAR KAPOOR,CHUNKEY PANDEY????

  • Now I believe this is pure media exaggeration and stunts via orders from above!!
    @Navin 3.21pm…that’s what I call a real up to date exposed Indian guy!! Nice 1 Navin. Keep up with that spirits and never bring religion to be a hindrance like how I am seeing many loyal fans of his real colour. You proved them wrong by accepting to be an Indian first before a hindu!!

  • Wife of Late Col.Santosh Mahadik who died fighting the militants: My both kids will join the Army.Daughter as a doctor and Son as a commando.

    Wife of Aamir Khan,who’s sitting safe in his house with security guards all around n minting crores:We feel very unsafe here,want to move out!

    #Difference!

  • As Raveena Tondon tweeted These Khans n other Muslims n AAPTards are not Happy after Modi became PM. There’s no other reason behind them uttering such bullshits. Bihar elections are over n the award wapsi by the so called pseudo intellectuals has been stopped. Muslims start everything n then cry foul after getting their a** kicked. e.g:- They first burnt many Hindus alive in a train in Godhra n when Hindus retaliated then they started crying foul n played victims. They’re doing it even now.

  • @Saksham, Finding sense in RGV comments make you look even more insane. He himself has insulted Hindu Gods many times. He’s just milking out of this situation for publicity as people has started to forget him. Plus, RGV and Aamir have been having some clashes since years.

  • What wrong did AamirKhan say ?? Is anyone proud to be in a country where politicians care more about cows than women getting Raped. 1/2

  • Why are Pakistanis so concerned about what happens here? You’re not even safe in your own country and you’re inviting people to your country? LOL

  • And what’s up with this Freedom Of Expression bullshit? If you have the rights to express your POV so do Others. You speak shit n people screw you back. That’s how it works. You have a heart to speak n we don’t??

  • @Marshall, Salman has just escaped that controversy on a close shave. Thanks to Sonam Kapoor, she has saved him from a (sick) reporter forcing him to say something on intolerance and take a stand.
    It was the only time I saw Salman feeling helpless.

  • This is d own creation of mind of some Muslims tht they r not safe in india because of a Hindu supporter prime minister modi ,which he isn’t…!

    Nd I can’t understand y Muslims r taking this Beaf thing so seriously, whts wrong if Indian politicians r trying to stop killing of cows?? Eat chicken, mutton nd leave Beaf, simple! !!! They r not baning food ,just want to stop d killing of cows .

    Is it a silly cmnt? If yes then don’t publish . Not much Idea about this topic :P

  • Yesterday I thought it was about Kiran decision to leave that’s why I was annoyed with Aamir but after going through some online news blogs I am fully convinced that this is topic is being misinterpreted and the side effect esp with @indicine happy to post any single left n right of Aamir now ,the side effect is
    1. People will become religious fanatics in this site. So disgusting!!
    Or
    2. Aamir will now be elevated to a National Hero…alias Mangal Pandey.

    Am with you Aamir. . Raveena case is different. Totally paranoid.
    @indicine is it not you guys that posted a letter of Aamir to Pm?
    An article of Aamir with Pm on sweeping India clean? Nah just wanted to be sure.
    For Pk kiddish excuses …..No one blaming Hirani too? Why did he not think that that is not proper esp being a hindu? And look who is talking OMG Paresh? Give me a break! I want to hear more from ppl like Ajay Akshay Hritik and Amitabh. What’s their take? Not from any drug addict relationship stricken mid 90s actress or anupama kher!!!

  • @i am groot, ur crossing the line !!!
    idiot write some sensible comments
    rather than uttering nonsense !!!
    This shows ur level of intolerance .
    You are of such low standard guy !!!

  • WTH man….. did anyone actually saw or read what aamir khan said… he said that intolerance is growing in our country… he never said india is an itolerant country…. its you moronic people who are again and agan sayng that india is becoming intolerant…..
    and fuck these bolywood celebs.. instead of supporting aamir, dey are criticizing him… shame on you people…. Even now in you comments you are talking about hindu and muslims…. did he ever said that intolerance against muslims is growing in the contry,.. no na.,… Den y target the muslims yaar… what is did bullshit.. “india is a hindu country” this single word is damn too intolerant.. y r saying dat india is a hindus country…. yeah v know dat der is a majority of hindus in india but dat doesnt mean k india is only a hindu country na….. please dont use such words brothers… dat really hurts every person belonging to other religion..

  • If freedom of speech is for intolerance supporters then it is also oposition.There is no intolerance in india this is a media and political hype.I hate these kind of intellecual posting there opinion for attention.Aamir is one of them.If he feel unsafe he is most welcome to leave.Stars are public figure they should spreed hope to people not like aamir.

Leave a Comment