Akshay Kumar’s Baby: Reader Reviews

Total Reader Reviews Submitted : 7

Lowest Rating : 3 stars

Highest Rating : 4.5 stars

Average Rating : 3.9 stars

Baby Review by GJ007: A predictable story with lots of thrills and solid performances.

To be honest, over expectations killed a lot of joy for me. Baby was getting extra-ordinary reviews from all critics and I went into the theater expecting a mind-blowing film. It’s a really good film, but Neeraj Pandey, who had mastered the art of conning his audience with unexpected twists plays it rather predictably this time.

So what is Baby? Baby is a 5-year trial program where undercover agents are trained to fight terrorism freely with a clause that Indian Government would never claim their identity as an Indian in worst case scenario. We have interesting actors like Danny, Neeraj regular — Anupam Kher, Rana and the terrific Tapsee to support Akshay in their mission.

The first half of the film was a bumpy ride where time was taken to give us all the characters. I got the feeling that Neeraj has lost it completely, but the second half of the film with it’s extremely well edited scenes is so high on thrills, they take your breath away more than twice!

Another impressive thing about Baby is, it more than once turns a cliche on it’s head. So here we don’t have the hero successfully defusing bombs at the last minute nor any overtly sentimental melodrama. What we get is SOLID ENTERTAINMENT!

Akshay plays his part exceptionally well. Easily one of his strongest performance. Danny and Anupam Kher lend good support. Tapsee in a small yet powerful scene leaves a lasting impression. The editing is terrific and the direction is quite good. The screenplay however is strictly above average. A scene where we see no traffic on Marine Drives is absolutely outrageous and annoying.

Neeraj however manages to get the required tension and intensity so well that I’m more than willing to ignore some of it’s flaws. He sets the mood, gives you clap worthy moments, extracts riveting performance from his cast and gives you an entertainer which is incredibly engaging.

Though muddled with logical loopholes, Baby is still a clear winner, thanks to it’s brisk pacing, sharp dialogues and terrific performances. Akshay and Neeraj have done it twice in a row.

Final Words: Go watch it. What are you waiting for?

Rating: ★★★½☆ 7.5 on 10

BABAJI’s BABY Review:: Thoroughly Engaging but won’t blow you off!!

**** This Review contains SPOILERS,move ahead at your own risk****

Finally watched my most anticipated film of the year: BABY directed by Neeraj Pandey.And it was my most awaited film for a reason as the same director had given us two exceptional films in A Wednesday and Special 26.Both these films were engaging,thrilling and had a gripping narrative that will hook you through the entire duration.So does BABY succeeds in doing so? Let’s find out!

BABY starts off with a bang with few brilliantly choreographed action scenes and never loses pace throughout the first half or I should say the entire length.Baddies make a menacing introduction through some brilliant dialogues.Akshay’s scenes with Madhurima are well shot and adequately timed,will not make you impatient for the main story.First half has some kickass dialogues but the story wavers and is’nt clear as to what’s going with the intoduction of so many characters.However there are some scenes that standout such as Akshay interrogating Taufeeq,Maulana’s intro.

Second half begins briskly with Tapsee and Akki in nepal,Tapsee shines in her limted role.Definitely one of the best moments of the film.The pace is never down,the thrills are there in almost every single frame.Anupam Kher enters the film in the second half and provides much needed comic relief.Akshay delivers one of his best performances,right from the first scene his absolutely brilliant but what let me down is the climax,though most critics have liked it.It seem rushed and things went too easily their way.If you have watched Argo,you will be left a tad disappointed with the climax.It is weaker in comparison and has every chances to leave you upset.It will be predictable for you.SPOILER***:I could’nt understand why the Saudi Police officer let them fly off when he was shown inspecting so seriously!

Overall a must watch as these kind of films are not made everyday in bollywood,it will keep you engaged and hooked at the edge of your seat throughout but a better climax would have made it a great film.Sometimes keeping too high expectations results in you leaving a bit disappointed something that happened with indicine at the time of PK.Definitely it is’nt Neeraj’s best work.I will rate it less than A wednesday and Special 26.


Akshay is fantastic throughout.one of his best performances.
Great support cast in Danny,Tapsee,Anupam and Rana.
Villains does geat job.
Action scenes are realistic,one of the best in a bollywood film.
Beautiful locales and great cinematography.


Story is unidirectional and is’nt multilayered.
Climax is a letdown if you have seen Argo.
No major twists,it’s quite predictable.

Rating: ★★★½☆

Baby Review by Nipun

Director Neeraj Pandey’s latest movie Baby is an engaging material, yet it could have been a smarter one!

The first half is decent and certainly lacks an intensity. Movie gets diverted to a few extents with a scene of around 5-6 minutes between Ajay and his wife. I feel they could have shortened that part! Also,the scene of a guy describing how they were taught to use weapons and so on didn’t click. I know the main purpose was to show the Good Muslims! But I think they should have shown it in another way! The second half was consistantly engaging and creates a tense situation whom you can genuinely feel, even though movie was predictable to some extent!

The performances were impressive! Akshay Kumar has delivered a stronge performance here and has been well-supported by Anupam Kher and Rana! Danny, Kay Kay Menon and the pakistani actor have played their parts well. Taapse Pannu impresses in her small part.

The dialogues were well-written. The action was realistic. Cinematography was good. Background score was suitable, but I feel they should have kept it simple in a few parts of “1st half”. The screenplay could have written in smarter manner, although it is still good. There were no unnecessary songs in the movie, which is a good step by the makers!

So over all, Baby is an engaging and brave movie which deserves your time thanks to the wonderful performances, consistantly intense 2nd half, realistic action and suitable BGM! Yet, it could have been a smarter one. The only reason why I still feel special 26 is a better film was the smartness in its screenplay! I am going with a three and one quarter stars for Baby. But as we don’t have such rating, so it is a strict three out of five rating for me! Watch it! Pandey again suceeds in creating genuine tense situations who make the film a good thriller!

Rating: ★★★☆☆

Baby Review by Vignesh

Just came back seeing Baby. One of the most anticipated films of this year.

Akshay and Neeraj come back and in what way! A very good start to this year, indeed.
As reports pouring in, and people reading tones of reviews, I would not emphasize much on the story line and the screenplay.

The film starts on a high note with lots of characters being established initially in the first half. The first half moves briskly and it is just about an hour and you see an ‘Interval’, in the midst!
The second half begins, again ‘brilliantly’ with the team moving to Nepal for an operation. Watch out for Taapsee in this initial segment — Best scene of the film! And then it tells about how this team catches Maulana and the further impact it has is what the second half tells about.
As everybody had been praising about Baby’s climax, TBH , I was a little disappointed by it since it had striking similarities with Argo and ofcourse our very own D-DAY! But, still the movie doesn’t make you lose heart and it still entertains you in whatever way it could. A little more subtlety in the screenplay would have done wonders. Anyhow, Baby is a brilliant attempt in an otherwise whimsical attempts that Bollywood keeps on attempting these days!

Could have been Neeraj Pandey’s best film till date but it somewhere lagged behind Special 26 and A Wednesday in my opinion.

1. Akshay’s riveting performance — Subtle and an absolute gem he was. (I hope, he does more films like these)
2. Brilliant casting with superb performances from everyone.
3. No attention to any love angle or songs.
4. Cinematography — Astounding.
5. Fast paced narrative.

1. Comparing to his earlier films, a little shallow.
2. Climax could have been better with little emphasis on a brisker screenplay.
3. Too much reliance on Akshay (Not bad, but still, I felt Kay Kay Menon had very little to do)

Finally, Baby is a must watch film, since it’s pretty rare that Bollywood makes such kind of Spy/Espionage Thrillers. Akshay in his lifetime act along with a top notch supporting cast is definitely worth giving your time, though with its share of flaws. Such films need to be encouraged!

Rating: ★★★★☆ A great watch, with its flaws!

Baby Poster

Baby Poster

Baby Review by SKY

First of all its first film of Akki which I seen in theatre since TMK.The film story is about a team baby who is on mission to find the terrorist who are responsible and willing to create terror attacks.It has four member Akki,Rana,Anupam & Tapsi and Lead by Danny.The whole screenplay of the movie run around how they able to catch the culprits.

Story don’t have anything new to offer and we have seen quite many films based on terrorism but its depend how you shaped up your writing and narration to keep the interest of audience and make them entertain.Baby had given full justice in that case.Screenplay I would say is very good but not outstanding as in first half and some portion in second half it drags specially climax also dragged a bit.Dialogues ate outstanding.Full marks to the writers for punching dialogues as well sarcastic and humorous in some parts.I loved Akki’s wife dialogue “Bas Marna Mat”.

Performances:-I must admit that I never thought akki is such a fine actor before I watched holiday.And now with Baby he won my heart with his performance.He is the soul of the film and unlike other Neeraj pandey film this time most focus is on Akki and he is fantastic.His dialogues,body language,sincerity and acting is superb.Take a bow akki for this performance but I have to say that I loved his performance in holiday more.

Danny is fantastic, after a long time we have seen this talented actor in important role with great screen presence. As a leader of team baby he is superb.Anupam kher had come in limelight in latter part of second half and his performance is terrific.He delivered great performance and able to leave his impact whenever he is on screen.Rana Dagubbati is good he don’t have much to do even his dialogues are negligible most of time he remain silent.

Tapsi Pannu has a cameo but she is very good in that too,she looks beautiful and done justice to her character.Her fight scenes with Sushant Singh were shoot brilliantly and it got thunderous applause from audience.She will remember for those scenes.
Pakistani Maulana was also good in his role so is shushant rajput. I had only issue with Neeraj pandey that they wasted K K Menon here.He I’d such a fine actor but there is not a much important role of him.

Direction-Neeraj pandey completed his hatrick with fantastic films back to back with a Wednesday,SPL 26,baby. He is a director to watch out in future.He had directed movie very well,able to engage the audience,open the layer one by one, used Acting caliber of all the actors barring kk Manon even supporting cast was superb.Though it is no great like his earlier work but still very good.Thanks for the Baby Sir.

In technical department film is first rate,superb BGM,cinematography,editing all were very good.Saudi locations were eye pleasing.

Scenes which stand out.

1. Akki first encounter with javed to get the truth from him.
2. Whole conversation between Akki with Taufiq.
3. Tapsi encounter with shushant and their fight scenes.
4. Whole the last 35-40 mins everything was good though climax is stretched.
5.Akki conversation with Shushant.
and many more.

I have watched the film on single screens and I had seen that they loving the film,so despite being avg start I think it will sustain well in coming days,may cross 100 cr a success for sure but deserves Hit status and great collection.

Thanks You Neeraj-Akki and whole baby team for wonderful experience.

Religion waale column may him Bold and Capital letters me likhte h “INDIAN”- Team Baby

Rating: ★★★★☆ from my side not a classic but brilliant movie nevertheless.

Baby Review by IamBollywoodFan

My Baby Review. Well, not review but you can call it an analysis. I will dissect the whole movie into it’s different aspects or features. The total scale’s value will be equal to 10. I will also explain them and at the end say whether I recommend it or not. Let’s go….

1) Plot/Story – 2.5/3.0

It has one of the most engaging story I have ever seen! The story stays true to the Genre and was every bit what I expected! The story takes many turns and is twisty so it should be watched very carefully and the dialogues should be understood. Even a 5 minute break between the movie will have you being confused and looking like a monkey! The last 40 minutes were highly publicized but were not as good the 40 minutes after the interval with Tapsee and Akshay.I’m not giving it 3/3 as the plot was a little confusing the first time you watch it and I got a little Anti- Pak and Anti-Muslim vibe though the vibe was very small!

2) Acting / Casting – 0.9/1.0

The whole team had a very limited screen time but gave a blockbuster performance! After the movie ended, I felt like I personally knew some of them and wanted more from the rest! Recsting Akshay was a great thing to do as he was one of the main reasons why I actually watched the film or why I liked it so much! Any other actor no matter how seasoned could not pull off his body language. Tarzan,Technician and Hulk were the nicknames given to Akshay-Anupam-Rana and they are totally fitting for them! I just wished that they would have used these names instead of their real names as they were too common (Ajay, Jay, etc) while the villains had the cool names. The villain(as there are many villains I will not say who is the main villain) was very menacing and has to be used in more Bollywood movies like Nasseruddin Siddiqui who was loved as a villain in Kick that they casted him as a Villain again in Badlapur!

3)Music/Background Score- 0.9/1.0

This is where I thought the film was lacking in. Don’t get me wrong! The background score was awesome and kept me engaged throughout the movie but it needed to have some getting used to. I would have been more engaged if they would have changed the Background Score in the 1st chase scene. There was only 1 bit of the romantic song and it was used to it’s utmost power. While the song Beparwah at the end came at a time when the people were filled with awesomeness and needed to become Beparwah as their country’s people will protect them!

4) Directing/Editing-2/2

It is a Neeraj Pandey film! What more do you want? This is his biggest movie till date and is better than Special 26 in my opinion. Special 26’s climax was really unpredictable but it left me wanting more as so much hype was built around how they will steal after the police has made preparation. The editing was real slick and never once did I feel like yawning!


Everyone was looking their very best and it was shot beautifully over many countries.

6)Dialogues/Dialogue Delivery- 1/1

The dialogues were really awesomely delivered and never felt forced! Well….except that Diwali one….It just doesn’t feel right that at such a crucial stage in their lives someone can make one liner joke….I didn’t get it anyways. The rest was absolutely great!

7) Trailer Expectations- 0/1 ( This the part where I loose my cool)

The trailer gave more screen presence to these characters than the actual movie! I went in there expecting a serious Anupam and he was used to provide Comic relief. Taapsee ha one of the best performances at the 20 minute screen time. I did not know what Baby was, and was expecting it to be revealed near the end of the movie but it is the first thing that is revealed and isn’t even that big of a deal.I was also expecting more of the Item song with Esha as I did not watch it on Youtube and wanted to experience it on the big screen!Kno what I mean guys?

8)Entertainment Value- 1/1

This is whether it was Paisa Vasool or not. Guess what? It was!

Total- 9.3/10 (1st day Baby collection as well :) )

Recommend it? Sure as hell! Watch it twice.

Baby Review by Sambuddha Mukherjee (aka Arjun Kapoor Fan)

Baby is the latest offering from writer director Neeraj Pandey,a man behind 2 higly entertaining realistic thrillers-a Wednesday and Special 26.Thus the expectations were high on the day film was announced that too with a versatile but underachieving superstar akki in lead role.

Baby is basically the name of a secret convert counter intelligennt unit formed by the best officers from our forces whose rask is to secretly counter all the terrorism threat to our country.this group has been assembled by danny denzongpa and has akki,tapsee,rana and few others in their group. while on a mission to counter a terrorism group akki realises that there is a very dreadful attack being planned by a maniacal terrorism mastermind played by maulana. His big idea is to spread fear among the mankind on their very existence and question everyones survival.His network spreads all over the world in places like kathmandu,istanbul,abu dhabi,new delhi and mumbai. After lot of hardwork team baby finally manages to know the big plan which is to do larger scale aerial attack in mumbai/delhi.

So will our unsung protectors-Team Baby manage to save us from this dreadful attack and if our heroes do succeed in their mission will they get their due recognition???

Now in last 2 decades we have seen several anti terrorism film but what sets baby apart from everyone is the handling of the subject by the genius called Neeraj Pandey.Also hats off to him for not including any needless melodrama,romantic track,songs or a jingoistic treatment to the subject of terrorism.

This movie is filled with several power packed scenes but watch out for the scene where Tapsee pannu has well choreographed fight with Sushanth or all the undertone humour in several scenes.

The dialogues r excellent and the locations,production design,cinematography,costume design,make up r all world class

In terms of performances everyone does a solid job especially the Pakistani actor playing the main villain in the film is a treat to watch

But the most satisfying thing for me about this film was to see the highly talented akki give a power packed performance in a solid film.

Having said that one has to criticise the films uneven pace and the overstretched climax.there r several scenes in the 2nd half which could have easily been trimmed but despite all of them being good the film does tire u in certain moments.the final scene also should have been more power packed after the huge build up

But overall baby is a satisfying watch and definitely among the top3 anti terrorism films made in india

Rating: ★★★★☆ 8.5 on 10



  • BABY has collected 5.10crs..it has literally crashed!! I don’t think 100crs is possible now :(

    As I said in my review,the climax was a huge letdown considering the buildup to it was so thrilling..and when the climax is weak,people go home unhappy and unsatisfied..
    The WOM unlike many people are saying is’nt that good.
    Compare BABY’s trending with Holiday or Special26,you will get to know.

    Also another point to be noted is that BABY is’nt getting support from family and female audiences.They have another film DKD to opt.
    I am really disappointed with these collections coz there are so many undeserving films in that 100crs club,BABY certainly deserved it..but won’t get it now.

    Sambuddha your prediction has gone wrong!!

  • I m always the first one to review and my review always is the last review in ur readers review article.

    I take it as a compliment as u want to always end ur review article with my review and there is a saying ”all’s well that ends well”

  • I am shocked because akshay kumar’s fan saying baby is not a good film because they want some south action story and some cheap dialogue and cheap acting by akshay kumar

    But this time baby’s story is superb
    mindblowing action
    And specifically akshay kumar doing great performance of his life
    For may view 4•5 out of 5 star
    •5 less because climex idea are taken by argo filmed by ben aflok

  • @indicine plz tell y baby has collected just 5.1cr today.everyone is luving the film.imdb rating is 9.1,critic rating is 3.4 all my frndz on fb and college r praising it.reactions in theatre was amazing and film trended well in weekend so y such a big drop?

    I m shocked
    @kshitiz this is the biggest shock id my bo prediction carrer.I m clueless y such a drop

  • Honestly speaking,all of the reviews published seem just variations of published critics reviews.honesty,I would like some refreshing honest reviews from the readers.no offense to the writers ;-)

  • still can blv baby collected just 5.1cr today.now 100cr and hit tag looks difficult.but baby has shown the most pequliar trending ever.it picked up well in the 4day weekend,received rave reviews from both critics and audience then suddenly showed decent drop on its first weekday!!!

    wtf is going on?

  • Read all reviews. And thanks@indicine for posting these reviews. Baby is indeed one of the better films that have come from Bollywood in recent times. Though, it did lack something when you compare it with Special 26 and A Wednesday (may be the entertainment part was amiss here). Still, it is doing well and I expect it to do well in the coming days too.

    @babaji: Don’t lose heart mate! The film is doing well, it did 5.90 yesterday. It should finish with 66-68cr till Thursday. The 2nd weekend could be around 20 cr and it can finish around 95 till the second week. So, I am guessing that it would finish between 105-108cr. This film definitely deserves to be among the top 15 films of Bollywood ever. Fingers crossed!

  • Its been first time that any review of my published on this kind of article.Thank you Indicine..
    But I have seen that Baby wom on social sites are extremely good but it doesn’t transform in collection as expected level.Let’s hope it will have decent lifetime.

  • So the lowest rating comes from me!
    BTW, I wrote a short review as I watched the film after 4 days of its release. So I was late which is why I didn’ t want to write a long review. I had given Long reviews for PK,HNY,BangBang,Kick etc!

  • Ajay vs Akshay, Who’s the bigger star?
    We will compare just the last movies.

    Ajay’s last film was Action Jackson which was one of the worst of all time.

    Directed by Prabhu deva:

    Deva is known for his successful south remakes like Wanted and RR, but also famous for lack of creativity as you can see all his movies… I mean the guy has ZERO creativity when it comes to direction.

    Action Jackson has also got poor critics rating and our dear @Indicine gave a big fat Zero ( it was the first time that indicine give a movie a ZERO..it never happened this before) but still the film collected its first weekend more than the lifetime of big films Happy Ending which was a Saif movie. do you know why?? because of Ajay’s name and his stardom.

    Action Jackson first weekend: 33 cr

    Akshay’s las film is Baby which hit theaters last Friday, it was a Neeraj Pandey movie, A man who is known for Writing and Directing the critically acclaimed movies A Wednesday and Special 26.

    Baby has received excellent reviews from critics, not a single critics has given bad review so far and it’s critically acclaimed film but the film collected its first weekend 36 cr compared to 33 cr of Action Jackson.

    Baby weekend: 36 cr

    I’m not comparing Baby vs Action Jaclson but what I’m trying to say Ajay is bigger than Akki right now.

    Stardom is judged based on the opening day and weekend collections so my above analysis showing that Ajay has a little more stardom than Akki.

    There was a time (2007/2008) when Akshay was way ahead of Ajay in terms of fan following and stardom but that time was over a long time ago.

    I’m not degrading Akki’s stardom but the truth is he is behind Ajay.

    Akki has three more movies his year but two of them (Gabar and Singh is Bling) has little chance to survive or recover it’s cost while Brothers has a every chance to become super hit and if Brother become superhit, then still Akii will be behind Ajay.

    I like Akki and I respect him but I had to say this because Akki fans were bashing Ajay at the time of Action Jackson and wanted them to know who is bigger star right now?? :)

    Now Akki fans may say Baby wasn’t a commercial film and it didnt get wide release but that wil not be an excuse coz Barfi which got limited released collected more than 100 cr.

  • I haven’t seen Baby yet but I’m going to watch it next Saturday.

    btw @sambudha was the only guy who predicted that akki will not replace Ajay in top actors of Bollywood despite Akki will have four release while Ajay ain’t have none.

    that was the first time I agree with @sambudha.

  • @Ajay Rocks you call yourself a sensible user and write such rubbish things.How could you compare a movie like Baby with Aj.I am not a huge Akshay fan but still the comparison is not reasonable
    Aj was a typical masala movie with songs(even though ridiculous)which were hits.Also Prabhudeva had made 2 blockbusters before Aj and was considered the best masala directors in the country.You can compare Aj with either RR or Holiday but certainly not with a movie like which has a niche audience base.

  • @ajay rocks zyaada uchal mat.films lije baby,holiday,s26,omg r 100Times better than any of ur ajays recent moviez.
    it’s just that ajay has rohit so he is ahead of akki but overall career wise akki>>>>>ajay

  • @Chalaa, first of all I never said what r u sying. I’m Ajay sir fan as u can see my id name.
    Second, I think you haven’t read my whole comment.
    I wasn’t comparing Aj with Baby. thy r totally different but what i was saying is the opening weekend.
    AJ has hit songs?? loolz more jokes please…. all song of AJ were pathetic n all were flop.
    Dude, A superstar is the one who can assure a big opening weekend even if the film is not a masala and Baby’s opening day was below par.

  • Indicine you wrote ‘Baby Review by Nipun’ but shouldnt it have been ‘Review by Baby Nipun’…?

    Anyways some buddha you say you clueless but why is that a surprise to you as we all have known for yrs you arent just clueless but also damn right stupid to boot…!

  • Heres my important list about best 5 reviews from above contenders….!
    (In particular order ofcourse otherwise whats the point of having a list eh nipun….!)

    1- Sky
    2- kShitij
    3- Gaurav
    4- Vignesh
    5- IAmKollywoodFan

  • @Ajay rocks: I don’t agree with u at all here.Akki was and is always ahead of ajay when it comes to b.o
    Comparing baby with AJ is’nt wise enough..
    Entertainment and Holiday both got similar or better opening than AJ.
    I can guarantee u Gabbar and SIB which u are writing off will open with 14-15crs if they get one chartbuster song and a solo release.
    Gabbar is scheduled for 1 may with avengers2,sunny leone’s mastizaade and DP’s Piku..
    Now if this the case what can u expect??
    It will get 1200screens!!!

  • Come on man, @Ajay rocks comparing Baby with Barfi? Barfi was a complete crowd pleaser. People love feel-good movies which exactly the reason why the initial low single screen footfalls started increasing quickly for PK in spite of high ticket rates. Barfi was a fun film, made for ‘family audience.’

    There are many problems with Baby.

    1. Bad marketing:

    Trailer launched in the first week of December. Fans were anyway waiting for the trailer with non-stop “Waiting for Baby.” trending on twitter, but the entire PK controversy in the fourth week of December completely overpowered Baby. Neutral Audience forgot about the film because every channel was debating, “What do you support, #Ban or #support pk?”

    They didn’t even promote it strongly. And in general after a film like Entertainment, there was little anticipation for Baby, and the marketing team had to use Neeraj Pandey’s name instead of Akshay because it was not a regular Akshay film. Also Neeraj is yet to become a brand like Bhansali, Johar or Hirani who have their own fan-following.

    2. Bad release date:

    If I was producing Baby I wouldn’t have released it in January. Why? Because Baby is not your regular mass film. A bulk of my revenue is gonna come from the mutiplex audience who in general, watch very few films a year. In December we have the big Aamir Khan starer who is referred as the multiplex messiah. His films are in general very well received and he has never failed in Christmas.

    After seeing PK, the multiplex audience won’t really come back to the theater just within a month that added to that is bad marketing. This is exactly the reason why Special Chabbis which was a more niche compared to Baby was a semi-hit because no multiplex film had released in December 2012. We had Dabbangg with Salman which was a complete masala film.

    3. Serious content:

    I will repeat the Barfi point again here. Baby is not a funny, light hearted film. Take any such film in recent times, from Queen to Bhootnath returns to Jolly LLB even these low budget films were decent successes because of ‘fun quotient.’

    Baby’s promos revealed it’s a no-nonsense drama. Special 26 was a more funny thriller compared to Baby. The last time I remember such serious drama, it was ‘Talaash’ but it was a suspense drama while Baby is a thriller.

    These are the reasons why I always predicted 85-105 crore lifetime collections. Honestly I loved the film so I wanted it to cross Rowdy Rathore, but at the back of my mind I knew it had a very little chance. And the ‘stardom’ which you’re talking about is very difficult to predict. The same Ajay gave 32 crore opener before Action Jackson. A lot of things come together to give an opening day. I mean, I am a huge fan of Raju Hirani, but for some reason I watched Pk on Monday, does that mean I am not a fan? Opening day = Fan following is a flawed logic. People watch films when they have time. I hope you get it.

  • @Ajay yes the songs were pathetic but still keeda was popular.Don’t you think that genre of movies also plays a part in ensuring good opening??
    @gj007 you are spot on as far as the opening of movies is concerned we also need to look upon various other factors like release dates,chartbuster songs and trailer .It isn’t only about the stardom of the lead men

  • @Babaji, @Gj007, take into account that Action Jackson is the worst reviewed movie of all time.
    most critics wanted so badly that AJ become flop and they were spreading non- stop negativity but still the film collected good numbers its first weekend because of Ajay.

    Forget about Singham returns, Ajay’s worst movie Action Jackson collected its first weekend same as Akki’s best movies like Holiday and Baby and that shows Ajay is bigger star than Akki right now.

    I said it before and I will say now, Akki has lost his stardom. he is behind Ajay.

    Baby’s release date was a perfect one for a film like a Baby,and it released on 2900 screens while AJ released 3200…see there s hardly any difference.
    It doesn’t matter if Baby has a niche audience or not, what matter is, it has got a wide release and also had the advantage of the big holiday (Republic Day).

    Btw @GJ007, Barfi and Baby are different movies but both were multiplex movies.
    I wasn’t comparing Barfi and Baby. I was just trying to show that Akki couldn’t assure a good opening for Baby.

  • @Chalaa, then baby had everything except chartbuster songs… Baby’s trailer had been received well and the movie released perfect date. it had a national holiday for Republic Day.

    @Gj007, Singham Returns might have the advantage of tremendous recall value but it didn’t have a chartbuster songs and it got only one holiday but collected 78 cr on its 1st weekend. so Baby didn’t live up to the pre-release expectations.

  • @gj007 you are absolute spot on, I also made same point when hny failed to sustain after huge weekend.As a movie-goers we can’t think to watch multiple films in a month,and a movie like pk which even I had seen thrice in theatre,it had huge recall value so these thing will subsequent affect the next releases in coming month.
    That also happened with Talaash just released after 2 weeks of Classy vs massy clash Jthj & Sos, so most of cibe goers either watched jthj or sos and both also, so when a serious kind of film like talaash came after them it got very good weekend but failed to sustain because of two reasons.
    1.Mixed wom 2.People had seen two big films already.
    It was a poor decision of Aamir to push Talaash from jun to Nov because I knew when it supposed to release in jun its buzz was too strong but once it postponed due to SMJ promotions and schedule the buzz killed by huge margin.

  • Tnx indicine for using my review! Ever since the new site launched you have been giving us some really great articles! Keep it up!

  • @sky

    First off, I really doubt whether talaash should be called a failure. An emotional suspense drama like Talaash did really well at 93 crores. Talaash was unfortunately compared with Aamir’s previous blockbusters like 3I and Ghajini.

    And to be very honest, I didn’t even bother to checkout JTHJ v/s SOs I saw both these films later on TV and hated them. I won’t call JTHJ as multiplex film. Shooting on foreign lands with a mega star director and superstar actor doesn’t make it classy. JTHJ had no content to back itself or else it would have grossed way more than it did. If you ask me what is a true romantic story, I’d say lunchbox. JTHJ was one of the many Yash chopra love triangles like silsilla, Veer Zara or Dil to pagal Hai. lunchbox was a matured and realistic love story which moved me because it was set in Mumbai.

    Talaash was also one of Aamir’s strongest performance, his best after Rang De if you ask me. Doesn’t matter what the collections were or what people think about the film (these clowns even make fun of a beautiful movie like Dhobi Ghat) I love Talaash. And I have argued about Talaash many times even on indicine. It’s one of the most underrated films of Aamir after Earth!

  • ha ha ha .. now these reviewers are hiding behind their horse tails to save their shameful face !!

    after giving such flattering reviews to their dear akkis films have not a single tissue in sight to wipe their tears and ****y..!!

    these self appointe d critics and all of them failed big time in reviewing the movie right!!

    and now they are giving excuses>>>!!! ha ha ha…

    in future readers are advised to go and follow my ratings and my comments than to follow these immature sycophants!!!

  • obviosly these people do not care about negative and true commenting cos they have prejudiced mind and fell they whatever lie they write for the sake of film is righrt and people should help films by watching and spending money over them so that their favorite star can sip his champagne sitting in his 100 crore yacht!!

    irrespective of whether poor people will lay down thier lives in pursuing their dreams!!!

    i have mentioned so many times to indicine to write balanced views but no.. they will always hype the movie with their own introduction of trailers and songs etc and parade the film..and now see the result..

    does anybody think this film will do any business today on a thursday???

Leave a Comment