Aamir Khan talks about ‘growing intolerance’

Just when the debate around the so-called ‘growing intolerance’ was subsiding, Bollywood superstar Aamir Khan has added more fuel to the debate. The actor also went on to say that his wife was considering moving out of the country.

Here’s what he had to say at the Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards:

“As an individual, as part of this country as a citizen, we read in the papers what is happening, we see it on the news and certainly, I have been alarmed. I can’t deny. I have been alarmed by a number of incidents”

“When I chat with Kiran at home, she says ‘Should we move out of India?’ That’s a disastrous and big statement for Kiran to make. She fears for her child. She fears about what the atmosphere around us will be. She feels scared to open the newspapers every day. That does indicate that there is this sense of growing disquiet, there is growing despondency apart from alarm. You feel why this is happening, you feel low. That sense does exist in me”

“People who are our elected representatives, people who we select to look after us for five years, state or centre… when people take law into their hands, we look upon these people to take a strong stance, to make a strong statement, speed up the legal process, when we see that happening there is a sense of security but when we don’t see that happening there is a sense of insecurity.”

“A number of creative people — historians, scientists — increasingly had a certain feeling in them, which they felt they need to express. For creative people, one of the ways of expressing their dissatisfaction or their disappointment is to return their awards. I think that’s one way of getting your point across”

“All individuals have a right to protest and they can protest in any manner that they feel is right as long as they are not taking the law into their hands.”

In response to Aamir’s comments on intolerance, actor Anupam Kher posted a few tweets on Twitter.

“Dear @aamir_khan. Did you ask Kiran which country would she like to move out to? Did you tell her that this country has made you AAMIR KHAN.”

“Dear @aamir_khan. Did you tell Kiran that you have lived through more worse times in this country & but you never thought of moving out.”

“Dear @aamir_khan. When did ‘Incredible India’ become ‘Intolerant India’ for you? Only in the last 7-8 months? #AtithiDevoBhavah”

“Dear @aamir_khan Presumed country has become #Intolerant. Wat do u suggest 2 millions of Indians? Leave India? Or wait till regime changes?”

“Dear @aamir_khan. #SatyamevaJayate u talked about evil practices but gave Hope. So even in ‘Intolerant’ times u need 2 spread Hope not Fear.”

Advertisements

157 Comments

  • Mr aamir khan
    I had a huge amount of respect for you but not any more

    You’re same as srk

    I hate srk for the bottom of my heart may I’ll never hate you that much but surely you have lost million’s respect

  • well aamir’s comments on feeling insecure in India and considering moving out are a shame to say the least.

    huge aamir fan but couldn’t agree with anupam kher more! where’s the SMJ Aamir who can spread hope.

    in times when our PM is pitching India to world, our top superstars, SRK & Aamir, embarrasing by making such statements.

    Ofcourse, India has its share of problems but I sincerely dont think that there has been any drastic deterioration in the last 7-8 months as aamir says. Infact, there have been worse times that the country has seen!

    Online people are commenting that all khans are congress guys, remember SRK & Salman hugged at Baba Sidduiqi (ex congress mla) iftar party…..Aamir started SMJ when congress was in power and ended it when BJP came in. In a way he is morally obligated to return the favour to Congress.

    Hope all this is untrue and hope that the Khans make some responsible positive statements. They’re hugely followed, not only in India but abroad as well!

    Unfortunate!

  • Two donkeys meets and said to each other “you are so nice and intelligent” finally agreed that onlyonly both of them aintelligent vide whole country has no brain

  • @babaji:
    Read these.. http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/bihar-simmers-before-polls-3-fold-surge-in-communal-incidents-after-bjp-and-jdu-parted-ways/

    http://m.timesofindia.com/india/Communal-violence-shows-24-jump-in-first-five-months-of-2015-shows-govt-data/articleshow/48167102.cms

    Look at your 3rd link buddha…..You blindly believe on what Hinduexistence/Muslimexistence post on their websites. It clearly shows your thinking capacity and mentality. I can smell you are a member of either MIM or BJP..

  • Where are the article on overseas collection top 20 and worldwide collection top 20.

    Post these articles so that we want to see the position of blockbuster film PRDP. And also we can see position changing films.

  • 1.In our country an state governor says Its Hindu rastra isn’t it intolerance?
    2.when a person go for Indian army to save the nation and his family members have been killed for eating Goat meet isn’t it intolerance???
    3.when sadhvi pragya, yogi adityanath, Mohan bhagwan threatens minorities and governments were silence isn’t it intolerance???
    4.when muzaffarnagar, Gujarat happens isn’t it intolerance???

    5.We choose India over Pakistan at the time of partition we choose Abul kalam over Jannah and RSS always pushes us to Pakistan isn’t it intolerance???

    6.We are suffering from all the hatred that is fair but when our pain is coming out in our tongue u suggests us to go Pakistan???

    Tum katl bhi karo toh charcha nahi hota hum aah bhi kare toh ho jaate hai badnaam!!!!

    We are with u SRK & Aamir Khan sahab aap ne India ka naam saari duniya May famous kiya hai

  • And whenever amir criticises something y does PK come in between. ..!!!

    same old question ki y Muslim practices weren’t criticised in PK. Arey did u guys suddenly forget ki Amir played a MUSLIM TERRORIST in Fanaa and in Sarfarosh he played a Cop who catches a Muslim terrorist played by naseerudin shah.

    pk was a movie where there has to b screenplay story editing and not a documentary or education dvd ki they hd to mock every religion for 20mins…!!!

    and in India 100s of movies hv been made on
    Muslim being questioned or found guilty for terrorism or anti social activities so if one film decides to focus in malpractices in Hinduism then wats wrong in that..???

  • My respect to aamir Khan increased since the release of PK movie… That is the best way of spreading Islam!. People will not like movies like my name is khan.. Even though it says clearly Islam says any one who kills innocent, it is as if he killed the entire humanity…. But most of the people give a thought when they were told in a entertaining way that fake god meet rich people quickly but for poor people need to wait in a long queue.

  • Aamir & Shah Sir r doing d rightest thing at d right time. If this intolerence is nipped in d bud then India will be d most benefited….. “Satyamev Jayate”

  • This is a disgusting comment to be very honest . After the comment by SRK and the award protest march this controversy was starting to get over but now after this comment this controversy will again become a national issue . This type of comment is not expected for a sensible person like Aamir Khan because he has been part of campaigns like Narmada Bachao Andolan, Incredible India, Malnutrition and Satyamev Jayate . Even if Aamir wants to say from Kiran’s point of view then also this is not the right place to do that . If he has problems then he can write a letter to the central government as a responsible citizen . I don’t know if SRK and Aamir are doing this deliberately to gain publicity or they genuinely feel what they are saying . In 2015 the behaviour of Khans has been absurd . Salman saying on Social Media that Yakub is innocent and should not be hanged . SRK saying India is Intolerant and now Aamir saying that her wife decided to leave India . This statement will definitely affect Aamir . He has always been politically correct and diplomatic but this time he addes fuel to the fire . Anupam Kher’s tweets were bang on target it is India who made Aamir Khan who he is . This is the reason why i always admire Hrithik, Ajay and Akshay . These guys always stay away from controversies and never indulge in such kind of statements . I hope all of them stay away from this situation and continue to do their work with honesty and sincerity . India has always been tolerant and such kind of statements will not affect India in any way . I hope this controversy ends as soon as possible . Cheers !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • These Khans have woken now, where were there eyes when the intolerance happening everywhere in the world? Yes, if you feel you can leave the country.

  • All the negative comments on this article clearly justify Aamir’s intolerance claims. If a person makes a certain claim about his nation’s current state, he has the complete right to do so. Aamir’s statement was a general one but it has been ‘communalised’ by a section of people.
    @x-zone I beg to differ, Anupam Kher is not a true Indian, he is just a ‘Modi-bhakt’. & before you hit me back on being judgemental, remember Anupam Chachu is doing the same.
    @sky Big B, Rajni bigger than Khans ? Isnt Big B the same person who used to hang around with Amar Singh (we all know his intellect) along with Amar Singh’s didi Jaya Jee, Rajni might be a south sensation, that doesn’t imply to the whole of India. In big cities in fact Rajni is nothing more than a butt of jokes. I doubt people even recognize him in the north. Khans are a global phenomena especially SRK (Salman and Aamir also have had a great holf off late especially Aamir in China) now please don’t claim that Rajni is a global Superstar, remember India is recognized by Bollywood and not Tollywood. Phew !! Get well soon. Rest of your views aren’t even worthy of a reply.
    @babaji ‘intolerance’ is a general issue, Why are we dragging it as a ‘Hindu-Muslim’ agenda. I can give you a 1000 links where even Muslims have been killed, & we discussing the killings on the basis of ‘religion’ rather than humanitarian grounds is another proof as to how there is rising ‘intolerance’ in our nation.
    I remember BJP goons claiming SRK is a Pakistani agent, these things need to realize big time that they don’t own the nation, there are 1.25 billion people who are equally important for the development of the nation but its anti-national BJP and RSS elements who are harming our nation’s growth and development big time.
    Coming to modi bhakts finally (people who pretend to be nationalists) the less we speak about him the better. I won’t speak much about him because this is not a political forum. But bhakts criticizing Modi doesn’t mean that someone is criticizing India. Remember Modi is a part of India, India is not a part of Modi. Hope you all enlighten your ‘common sense’.
    Thank You.

  • I fully support Anupam Kher here. This country made Mohammed Aamir Hussain Khan the AAMIR KHAN. Yes, even I ask the same question to him especially his wife, Kiran…. which country are you going to move out to? Yes, India has some issues but don’t all the countries have their own issues too?
    You should never ever turn your back on the people who made you the superstar that you are today. You should not leave the country that gave you food, shelter and education etc…

  • All box office Pundit (Boollyeood website nd trade ) r now confuse … wht Verdict give to PRDP… average .. hit or….. flop…. too much fun… #prem doob gaya.. rocks

  • jis din is globe mei rehne wale pranee insaan ban kar jeena shuru kr denge us din india to india poore world mei intolerance ka khatma ho jayega.mere bhaiyo bhul jao is dharm geeta,kuran jaisi chooti cheejon ko.ye tumhare liye banayi gayi hai.tum inke liye nahi bane ho.taki tum jindagi ko saleeke se jee sako.apni man ko man samjho apne se badon ka aadar kro.apne family ke prati,desh ke prati apni jimmedari samjho.apne jeevan mei anushashan, manavta,pyar ,samman jaisi cheejein la sako isliye in sab kitabon ko likha gaya tha,in dharmon(islam,hindutva,isaaee etc.)ka janam hua tha.isliye nahi ke tum in sab ke liye janwaron ki tarah aapas mei lado.dekha jaye to in dharmon ki koi aukaat nahi hai maanavta ke dharm ke saamne.manavta hi sabse bada dharm hai.lekin durbhagya ye hai manavta kisi dharm ke roop mei eslablished nhi hai.isliye mere bhaiyo insan ban jao.plz plz insan ban jao.jameen pe padi lashon ke uthne ke baad agar kisi anjaan teesre aadmi se ye poochha jaye ke yahan kiski maut hui thi to wo sirf yahi kahega kisi insaan ki.sirf insaan ki.insaniyat ko marne mat do…plz plz plz plz plz

  • Prdp’s gross India collection = 279 crore (koimoi)
    Prdp’s gross overseas coll. = 87 crore approx (taran)
    So total worldwide collection = 279 87 =366 crore that too in 11 days collection…..!

  • Then who is stopping you in this country
    Please go where you feel safe
    You are spreading negativity
    Our country don’t require greedy actors like you
    Please leave
    God bless you

  • Anupam kher is confused as he is becoming old yed we are tolerant country bcoz we are tolerating him sincd his debut picture and prdp we just got want to rid of him

  • As a proud Indian and as someone who has many Muslim friends who live their life happily in India, I’m hurt by Aamir’s comment as well. To me, he’s always been smartest among 3 big Khans who doesn’t like to get involved in such issues. This is why his comments came off as a surprise to me.

    Some people might think he’s just stating his opinion which might be true, but there’s difference between having an opinion and stating them on public. Just like calling a black person black in US would be factually correct, but a very inappropriate thing to say. Are they tolerant? Same thing applies here, Aamir could have made his point in a sensible way instead of adding fuel to the fire.

    I also want to clear that even if you believe India is intolerant, then it has been like this since years when Congress was ruling this country. I wonder why these guys waited for years to make such statements under BJP’s government?

    Now I don’s support BJP blindly, I hate some of their members who make comments against Indian Muslims and Hindus of lower caste, but the difference is they are probably uneducated politicians and very few people pay attention to them unlike in case with stars like Aamir and SRK who have millions of blind followers. They command much more attention than those small politicians, which gives you added responsibility to carry yourself nicely and think twice before speaking on any controversial matter. It’s also a shame many of Indians, especially Indian Hindus can go against their nation in order to support their favorite stars.

    They are forgetting they are who they are because of India and Indians of different religions who loved them for years. Now as I have written before even European and American countries are intolerant when it comes to white and black people, it could be even worse for outsiders like Hindus and Muslims. I also know that none of these stars want to go to Pakistan due to obvious reasons and Pakistani actors want to come in India and work in Bollywood, is it intolerance? Which place is most tolerant for you?

    India is probably the only country where so many people of different religions live happily together with the feeling of “Bhaichara”. It could be the most tolerant country in the world. I never thought I would have to say this thing to Indians.

    The worst thing about his statement was that he used his wife Kiran as a scapegoat to make such statement. Even if we believe Kiran did say it to him, does it mean she would have said it on public in front of millions? I don’t think so. I also feel bad for her that she may feel shy to go out in public now due to this incident. At least he shouldn’t have dragged her wife into this, especially if he agreed with her statement. What was the point of using her name if you share same opinion?

Leave a Comment