Shivaay Hit or Flop: Business Economics

Ajay Devgn’s Shivaay was undoubtedly one of the biggest releases of year and also one of the costliest. The beginning to the campaign was outstanding as the Shivaay trailer was unanimously applauded for its action and scale. Post the trailer, the units that were put out failed to sustain interest and the film eventually opened below expectations on its opening day.

Shivaay did well on the Diwali holiday and has since sustained, but collections never hit the kind of levels that a big film like this was expected to. It needed a couple of 20 crore plus days, but nearly a week after release, the 15 crore mark has only been surpassed once.

The reason it needed those big days is the high costs. The two major circuits combined had to collect somewhere around 75-80 crore just to cover costs of the distributors, but at the end of 6 days Mumbai and Delhi-UP have collected approximately 34.75 crore. Shivaay is not even at the half way mark and the first big week has already passed.

The second weekend will be crucial. It has to sustain and grow, else Shivaay will join the growing list of big films that have disappointed at the box office this year.

Breakdown of the Economics:

  • Cost of Production – 90 crore
  • Print and Advertising – 20 crore
  • Total Cost – 110 crore

Note: Cost of production does not include Ajay Devgn’s acting or direction fee, he is the producer.

Recovery from non-theatrical:

  • Satellite – 40 crore
  • Music – 10 crore
  • Others – 5 crore
  • Total – 55 crore

We have also been informed by reliable sources of the same film, that Shivaay needs to collect Rs 120 crore to cover distributor costs.

Here is how much the film needs for the various box office verdicts:

  • Below 110 crore – Flop
  • Below 130 crore – Average
  • Above 130 crore – Hit
  • Above 170 crore – Super Hit
  • Above 220 crore – Blockbuster
Advertisements

70 Comments

  • So many disappointing films this year:

    Mohenjodaro
    Shivaay
    Great Grand Mast
    A Flying Jatt
    Baar Baar Dekho
    Housefull 3
    Fan
    Azhar
    Raaz Reboot
    Rocky Handsome
    Befikre

  • impossible to gain hit verdict. it will b just avg grosser & enter 100cr club thanx to manipulation (5-15% is normal but in shivaays case its currently 20% clearly indicating manipulation )

    Actually at a time when kids like sushanth r scoring 133cr grosser ajay doesn’t want to live with the humiliation of not entering 10cr club so all these cheap tactics. It’s fine but Public Sab janti hai boss

  • @indicine here you aren’t including Ajay Devon’s fee in the cost of production because he is the producer but I’ve noticed for every SRK movie, you’d consider the satellite rights as his ‘assumed acting fee’ despite him being the producer. Why?
    #Kaali

    • @Kaali, each film has different economics and for big stars it’s about perception too. A film like Sultan will cover all costs from satellite, music, digital and overseas.. that does not mean it’s a hit at 20 cr domestic. It important to recover investment and be profitable for all investors involved. Dilwale, local distributors lost money. YRF suffered losses on Fan. And the total itself wasn’t big enough to make the two films perception hits either.

  • It means will be flop, bec it will not cross 100cr in any case.

    only in one condition he can cross 100cr that’s through manipulation which he is doing from first day still behind ADHM. ADHM will be a clean hit while Shivaay will be a clean hit.

    when it comes to a winner there is no doubt ADHM was a winner from first day even before a month ago . finally only one advice Ajay devgn should stop booking Diwali dates.

  • Flop. 110 cr itself looks very difficult. No chance for Average or Hit. And Blockbuster?. 220 cr for an Ajay Devgn film, let him first cross 110 cr without Rohit Shetty franchises.

  • Maybe Shivaay won’t attain the hit verdict… But it will surely thrash the lifetime collections of tinystar’s content rich solo festive weekend release Fan.
    #Happy for that.

  • After this debacle, Vimal Pan Masalawala shouldn’t even clash with Rajpal Yadav.
    His dirty tactics have failed big time, he was claiming that people don’t make good movies in Bollywood these days, what about the piece of crap he’s himself made?
    Go back to your cave Devgn.
    #Kaali

  • Edited :

    It means will be flop, bec it will not cross 100cr in any case.

    only in one condition he can cross 100cr that’s through manipulation which he is doing from first day still behind ADHM. ADHM will be a clean hit while Shivaay will be a clean flop.

    when it comes to a winner there is no doubt ADHM was a winner from first day even before a month ago . finally only one advice Ajay devgn should stop booking Diwali dates.

  • It will be a flop ,Sad but True … Feeling sad for ajay’s effort 2 make this movie…. These type of movie’s deserve a solo release and bollywood industry again proved that their is no unity here ,its full wid ego and what matters the most is money….
    Also feeling sorry for the audience that they rejected shivaay for a movie like adhm (shivaay was not a masterpiece but its a good attempt ,and far better than adhm)
    Now, we have no rights 2 say that bollywood didn’t try something different… if u can’t welcome an experiment.

  • After this epic failure, Ajay Devgn will never ever dare to book a Diwali festival. Now only for the makers of Enthiran 2/Robot 2 to officially book Diwali 2017 so that Ajay can save his career as soon as possible.

  • Srkfans r burning r creating more and more negativity against shivaay….I think u forgot srk movies releasing soon…. U will b getting fitting reply by all Adians…bhagoda raees will b flop

  • @indicine

    You have rated the unanimously praised trailer of Dangal as 8/10 but rated a highly ridiculed trailer of Mohenjodaro as 7/10 or the highly tacky A flying Jatt as 7/10.

    Are they really so close? Or are you using different looking glasses?

  • Hahaha… Now some gigastarwalas are forcing #indicine to declare 80cr grosser Billu a hit. I would like to call it a nice move by srkians. Because in future their gigastar doesn’t have any chance of surpassing 100cr mark.

  • Evan how much Ajay manipulated it’s surely be a flop , it will finish before 100 cr and ADHM will finish 100-110 cr which is hit .

  • how much you creating negativity if the movies is good then people are surly will watch shivaay nothing then FAKE vfx and music of ADHM is very good music are good and actor is good looking . compare to Aajay devgan who lookis like riksawala

  • Ajay is real a Singham, who is not a Bhagoda like SRK.

    SRK has huge ghanta-dom instead of stardom.

    Long live Ajay Devgn who is a Man, not a coward like SRK. A half-age actor (Bajirao Mastani
    ) movie completely raped SRK’s ghanta-dom movie (Dilwale).

  • @iamakn

    Blabbering on Shivaay’s manipulation!!! Do you know HNY 1st day manipulation >>>>>> Shivaay 1st week manipulation? Still shamelessly chanting on Shivaay’s manipulation!

  • this arjun youngistan is hell bent on declaring ranbeer kapoor a superstar. ..dude for ur kind of information the film didn’t collect money because of ranbeer. ..u can check other news articles no one is crediting him for the movie collections. ..even before release the clash was known as ajay vs kjo not ranbeer. …….and talking about superstardom. ..india has 29 states and he is known in hardly 9-10 cities. ..not states mind u. ….to have a superstardom u should have pan india following which only khans and hr has…akki is one dimensional he does either mass movies or class movies….and ranbeer is not even known in masses. ..so be in reality don’t exaggerate success. …..

  • @challa

    Fan released on Ram navami holiday. Also it got another holiday on Tuesday due to Mahavir jayanti (you can check #indicine’s article). Then how does it become a non holiday release???

    If it was not that commercial then WTH YRF spent 120+cr for it??? Excuse dena chhodo and reality ko accept karo.

  • oh soo the difference between the budget of this 2 films is just 7Crs….great

    and we used to think the budget of Shivaay is much more like 40-50Crs more than ADHM budget

  • #Shivaay s not a good product , so makers should accept it n focus 2 make something better than that in d near future.
    social platforms r just 10-15 % , u cant fool real movie going public by any gimmick. They want a good film , thats it. its not about stardom or negativity ,
    it s about quality , simple.

Leave a Comment