Horrrible movie.Poor direction and extremely poor acting.I am surprised to see such reviews for such a movie.Totally misleading.There is no flow and all scenes are cooked up like a kinder garden story,no originality at all.

Just to add,I am a big fan of Aamir and really liked Lagaan and Thaare Zameen Par.Those were awesome movies.But this one is real crap.The hero is just good for photos,he has no acting skills at all.And surprisingly Rahman also below average in this movie.Genelia was good to watch but dialogues spolied all the fun.

I serioulsy doubt if all these “excellent”,”wonderful” reviews written by real viewers or just another promotion stunt to hype the movie??

You cant compare this movie with the class of Lagaan nd Tare Zameen Par. I like’d this fun movie a lot!!.in its own way, The cast was good. And Mr i am not a fake person giving these comments. As you were not fake.

coollllllllll movie………………
ad genliya with imran is to cool

Brilliant job done by all…

Right from main Actor to all the team…

Even I don’t have word to define…………….

Brilliant………

allswell: I know that u would be surprised that I didn’t like Rang de Basanti and I loved all the mentioned movie, but I asked a question and u didn’t answer (I’ll make it more clear): What r the negative points in these 3 movies?? Was it the direction, prodcution, acting, music and songs, the script?? I need an answer whether u did allswell or any other commentator, just want to know. If I loved these movies and didn’t like Range de Basanti for the following reasons:

Rang De Basanti: I found only the comedy scenes were good, the script wasn’t, show during the movie a flash back about Bagahat Singh didn’t like it (cause I loved the movie : The legend of Baghat Singh) and had a feeling that Aamir just loved to make some copy of this movie and just loved to play the roll of Baghat through this movie. Aamir’s acting in the last scene was poor, when he was crying. That’s some of the reasons therefore I didn’t enjoy watching it.

I know.. u all didn’t watch the remake of Umrao Jaan ’cause u thought that the original was better!! Dear.. after watching the remake, I watched the old one, as many people told me the same – just to compare both and found the following:

- In the remake, the director rectified some flaws in the original and they are:
a) In the original, Rekha acts as a prostitute, she doesn’t mind the guy who used to flirt with her to receive gifts from him then to sleep with him. That’s the job of all prostitutes and the main story is that Umrao Jaan or “Ameeran” was a good girl from a good family and wasn’t born in this filthy society as they kidnapped her ( so the director has to show that she’s a decent woman and rejects to be a prostitute ( AND THAT’S WHAT THE DIRECTOR OF THE REMAKE VERSION DID)
b) In the original: Her lover tells her that his mom chose for him a bride.. means he can’t marry her, and she doesn’t show any anger, she accepts and during their dialogue, she shows him that whatever makes him happy would make her happy too. ( I can’t remember the dialogue, but something like that). Lateron, one day he knocks her door to invite her for the wedding, and (see Rekha’s reaction in the movie!) she hits him with her both hands and start crying loudly and accuse him!! ( IN THE REMAKE.. AISHWARIYA SHOWS HER JEALOUSY WHEN ABHISHEK TELLS HER THIS FACT, THAT HIS FAMILY WANT HIM TO MARRY SOMEONE ELSE)
The remake was (perfect) with no flaws at all, the script, the direction & production, the performance (specially Aish, she deserved best actress award for this movie), the songs, the cast, everything was interesting. ( I saw it 3 times) and don’t tell me some minor reasons which, as someone mentioned, that Aishwariya couldn’t speak Hindu correctly and 4get all the good thing about the movie!!

Saawariya: without explaining anything, was the best romantic movie with best music and direction in Indian Cinema ( I think people who didn’t like never notice all these stuff!!)

Tararampum: I mentioned already, under LS2050 my opinion ( a perfect entertaining family package with no flaws and with best musics.. this movie can’t be compared with the latest “Thoda Pyaar Thoda Magic as it was bad in the script and a boring one)

I’ve explained whatever I could in brief.. now could u all tell me what you didn’t like about these movies. Thanks

Good moive

Fathiya you seem to have a lot of time with you writing such a long reply. but i will try to be trese and concise for my reply

About umrao jaan ( I have watched both original and the duplicate)
These r the flaws in the duplicate
a) nawabs of luknow do not grow beards(historically incorrect)
there r no deserts in lucknow(geographically in correct)
b)abhisek is bad in acting I may even say worst
C)the music of the movie sucked
D)the acting of supporting characters was awful

More ever the movie was totally dissapointing and guess who agrees with me Amitabh bachchan (you mave watched his critical remarks did not you )

Moreever the film was biggest flop of its time

So these r the reasons abt other films i may report in due time

Fathiya the point is that u dont like the movie fair enough. But majority do and thats what matters! So accept it, you cant change people opinion.

o gr8 movie. aamir did it again. he is way ahed frm those srks and salmans.

wat a fine movie. i salute aamir.

Cute, simple and honest film!!! A rare breed in indian cinema….

Awsome!!!! MOVIE LOVE’D ALOT, MONEY GOT ITS WORTH.

Dear Allswell: Well.. It’s not that I don’t accept the fact u said, it’s not that I want to prove that I got a good taste in movies or observe some flaws and others don’t. It a gathering her, connecting with each other and sharing opinions, which way we evaluate any movie. Believe me.. during all these years, and as a Bahraini, used to watch lots of movies with my families, friends and used to love some movies and found out later that the movies were flop or average. Therefore I’m here, just to know which way, as u are all indians, and on what basis do u evaluate any movie, which way u think, and what’s the reason for the flop of any movie we found it good.
I’m not an Indian therefore I don’t know about all what you mentioned, and also never knew about BigB’s opinion. Ok.. if u guys never observe any good stuff in any movie but some minors e.g. there’s no desert in Luknow, or nawab never grew beards, ( we, as other nationalities aren’t aware of all these stuff, when we watch a movie, we’re interested in the story, the performance, the music & the songs, the direction & production and nothing else.
u said that Abhishek’s acting was bad and the team work, no.. he wasn’t bad at all, and also u didn’t comment on what I noticed in both the original and the remake. Do u have anything to say further? And what about Aishwariya’s performance? She was excellent in the last scenes of the movie, made me cry.

And what about Tararampum, Mangal Pandey & Saawariya?

oh thts reallyyyyyyyyyyyyyy a beauty its gud to see both the stars ……..
its rocking specially genelia oh my god i cant believetht she will act like this fulllllllcredit to amir and imran
nic movie

Its ameging brillient movie i have seen this type of good movie after a long time. Every younger those want to see film on real friendsheep he must watch this movie. After Kutch Kutch Hota hai in this movie real defination of love.

hey gr8 movie superb acting by each n every one…Honestly I didnt like the climax, but the performance by Genelia and Imraan, when surrounded by the cops, makes an impact.

hey, its awesome movie, blockbuster, no word to discribe it….. people often try to find out mistakes in movie, but in this tendency they neglect acting, songs, and quality of the movie. Its completly for youngees. There is no such movie unless TARE JAMEEN PAR, makes good impression or in viewers mind, so apart from all other movie this is much batter one. One cant make any comparison between anything. Every movie has its own way to entrain people….

Hi! This is so nice Movie, I really like it, Mostly Completed qulities are present here.

I think its a cool movie and a muct watch for Youngsters

http://www.iwebie.com/jaane-tu-ya-jaane-na-a-review